HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Main » General Discussion (Forum) » Dear Christian-bashers, h... » Reply #158

Reply #158


Response to mistertrickster (Original post)

Tue Apr 10, 2012, 05:36 AM

158. The fact that you've trotted out this list as, presumably, slamdunk examples of "bashing", says alot

In reality, the vast majority of them are no such thing. A couple are over the line, Smokey, but really.. most of them aren't and if you're trying to establish some pattern of widespread persecution, I don't think you've made your case.

And furthermore you've sort of shot it in the foot, much as this same tired argument (sorry, "call for respect") often shoots itself in the foot, in several key ways which I will elaborate upon as I break down your examples.

  • First, I'd like to posit a ground floor axiom for the purposes of this post, and that is, if expressions of skepticism are bigoted, then so are expressions of belief. "God is Pretend" is no more or less bigoted than "Jesus loves you". "I believe in God" is no more or less bigoted than "I don't believe in God, I don't believe in your god", etc. etc. etc. I will refer to this Axiomatic assertion, herewith, via this sequence of symbols: !A!

  • The second axiom I'd like to propose is the assertion that there is NO relative, objective measure by which one can distinguish "reasonable" or "logical" religious beliefs from any other kind. So if questioning Jesus's resurrection is off limits, then so is questioning the existence of the God Quetzlcoatl, the assertion that there is literally a Mt. Olympus upon which resides Zeus and the fellow stars of his metaphysical reality drama, the assertion that the Earth is only 4,000 years old, etc. I will refer to this axiom by this: !B!

  • For instances of Special Pleading, I will use this indicator: !C! I'm going to hope, by now, we all have an idea of what special pleading is- often, in these arguments, we see !C! combined with !A! but particularly with !B!.



    1) You do NOT get to make the name of your own superstition mean "good person" because doing so screams that those who do not share it are bad people - and all the disingenuous BS in the world will not change that loathsome lie.

    And the problem is? You've never heard anyone try to claim that "Christian"="Good Person" (and, conversely, clearly bad people who call themselves "Christians" aren't Real Christians because, again, they're "bad people"?) MT, are you saying it's NOT a "loathsome lie" to assert that only believers in one religion or another are the "good people"? Shit, I think it's a VERY loathsome lie. Or perhaps the problem with this quote is just the one, word, "superstition". If that's a problem, I would refer it back to both !A! and !B!


    2) I think "Christians" are probably the most harmful entities on this planet right now. No single group has caused more bloodshed and harm to the living beings on this planet.

    Whether or not this assertion could be backed up with statistics, facts, data, or whatever, it's still bashing. On that, we agree. Over the line.

    3) I don't bash individual Christians. I bash the idea of Christianity which very much does need to be bashed. With a few exceptions, that's what I see the majority of athiests on DU doing. If it bothers you so that your religion is being bashed, and you take that as a personal affront from all athiests on DU, perhaps your belief is not nearly as strong as you thought.

    This one, too, is over the top.

    4) Christianity can be used to justify many different and contradictory conclusions which makes it pretty much worthless as any kind of standard to live up to.

    The first part is a fairly obvious piece of observation that can be applied to just about any belief system. The second is subjective opinion. I think this post points up a weakness in logical framing of arguments, but I wouldn't file it under bashing. Maybe just poor reasoning, or debate skills.

    5) I am convinced that religious belief is delusional at best, and a variety of mental illness at worst. Folks displaying those characteristics are hard to support for leadership positions outside the asylum.

    Another example of subjective opinion. Note the use of "I am convinced". Were I to make this sort of statement, I might qualify the 2nd part as well with an "I believe" just to reiterate that point, but this person is stating their opinion. They are entitled to their opinion.

    6) I don't even believe he <God>exists, but instead is a made up myth used by groups over the centuries to control people and politics. If that makes me a god-hater I will wear that badge proudly.

    A clear example of !A!

    7) I believe everyone has a right to believe in anything they want. I also believe people have a right to say they think those beliefs are dangerous, absurd or ridiculous.

    I'm really scratching my head as to what could possibly be the fucking problem with this line. For all I know, I wrote it. It sounds like something I would say.

    8) Get your religion out of my government or get another Religion.

    This is a political sentiment, not a religious one, nor is it bashing of religion nor is it bashing of Christianity.

    9) Want Your Ideas Respected, Sir? Get Better Ideas....

    Okay, I think we all know who wrote that. Another statement I find extremely hard to find fault with.

    10) Religious people want their ridiculous beliefs placed off limits. Why? Too embarrassing to have to defend them?

    And, again, what is the alternative, then? NO beliefs may be criticized, ever, or analyzed or even made fun of, because they're someone's special religious belief? The Rapture guy who keeps getting the date wrong? The Westboro Baptists? Frank Chu? Where does it end? ....This one hits all 3: !A!,!B!,and !C!.

    11) I ridicule the ridiculous. I care little who or how many decided to make it the central focus of their life.

    Presumably, you think that people should NOT ridicule the ridiculous, or what they consider ridiculous, which really means no one should ridicule anything, because everything is probably ridiculous to someone and not ridiculous to someone else. !A! and !C!





    You should have stuck with #2 and maybe #3. The rest of your examples only serve to torpedo your argument, not fortify it.







  • Cannot reply in locked threads

    Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

    Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
    Replies to this discussion thread
    Arrow 171 replies Author Time Post
    mistertrickster Apr 2012 OP
    cthulu2016 Apr 2012 #1
    cherokeeprogressive Apr 2012 #2
    cthulu2016 Apr 2012 #6
    Electric Monk Apr 2012 #59
    Union Scribe Apr 2012 #150
    Humanist_Activist Apr 2012 #3
    The Straight Story Apr 2012 #12
    Humanist_Activist Apr 2012 #17
    The Straight Story Apr 2012 #33
    Humanist_Activist Apr 2012 #41
    SidDithers Apr 2012 #32
    peacebird Apr 2012 #4
    RKP5637 Apr 2012 #24
    Humanist_Activist Apr 2012 #52
    hobbit709 Apr 2012 #162
    Union Scribe Apr 2012 #5
    mistertrickster Apr 2012 #9
    sadbear Apr 2012 #10
    mistertrickster Apr 2012 #13
    sadbear Apr 2012 #14
    deucemagnet Apr 2012 #166
    Union Scribe Apr 2012 #16
    cherokeeprogressive Apr 2012 #18
    Union Scribe Apr 2012 #111
    Fumesucker Apr 2012 #7
    Chemisse Apr 2012 #161
    Humanist_Activist Apr 2012 #8
    mistertrickster Apr 2012 #11
    Humanist_Activist Apr 2012 #19
    mistertrickster Apr 2012 #34
    Humanist_Activist Apr 2012 #46
    TalkingDog Apr 2012 #159
    deucemagnet Apr 2012 #169
    neverforget Apr 2012 #15
    Honeycombe8 Apr 2012 #20
    Luminous Animal Apr 2012 #21
    Humanist_Activist Apr 2012 #26
    mistertrickster Apr 2012 #31
    provis99 Apr 2012 #35
    cherokeeprogressive Apr 2012 #38
    sadbear Apr 2012 #44
    cherokeeprogressive Apr 2012 #48
    Union Scribe Apr 2012 #110
    Humanist_Activist Apr 2012 #117
    Hugabear Apr 2012 #73
    mistertrickster Apr 2012 #75
    Humanist_Activist Apr 2012 #77
    RainDog Apr 2012 #97
    Marrah_G Apr 2012 #143
    RainDog Apr 2012 #146
    Tom Ripley Apr 2012 #144
    Warren Stupidity Apr 2012 #167
    mistertrickster Apr 2012 #27
    xfundy Apr 2012 #91
    Politicalboi Apr 2012 #22
    mistertrickster Apr 2012 #25
    Politicalboi Apr 2012 #36
    mistertrickster Apr 2012 #51
    provis99 Apr 2012 #66
    provis99 Apr 2012 #39
    mistertrickster Apr 2012 #53
    Humanist_Activist Apr 2012 #60
    provis99 Apr 2012 #68
    Humanist_Activist Apr 2012 #69
    mistertrickster Apr 2012 #76
    Humanist_Activist Apr 2012 #93
    Union Scribe Apr 2012 #113
    Tom Ripley Apr 2012 #23
    dmallind Apr 2012 #28
    OffWithTheirHeads Apr 2012 #29
    sylvi Apr 2012 #148
    got root Apr 2012 #30
    cherokeeprogressive Apr 2012 #37
    sadbear Apr 2012 #40
    mistertrickster Apr 2012 #43
    cherokeeprogressive Apr 2012 #45
    mistertrickster Apr 2012 #42
    Humanist_Activist Apr 2012 #50
    mistertrickster Apr 2012 #55
    Humanist_Activist Apr 2012 #63
    mistertrickster Apr 2012 #70
    Humanist_Activist Apr 2012 #74
    mistertrickster Apr 2012 #79
    Humanist_Activist Apr 2012 #87
    Marrah_G Apr 2012 #141
    JoeyT Apr 2012 #142
    Hissyspit Apr 2012 #145
    UnrepentantLiberal Apr 2012 #149
    mtnester Apr 2012 #154
    pacalo Apr 2012 #155
    idwiyo Apr 2012 #157
    Gore1FL Apr 2012 #114
    got root Apr 2012 #49
    Humanist_Activist Apr 2012 #58
    Skittles Apr 2012 #47
    Solly Mack Apr 2012 #54
    RainDog Apr 2012 #56
    RFKHumphreyObama Apr 2012 #57
    NYC Liberal Apr 2012 #61
    SpartanDem Apr 2012 #62
    mistertrickster Apr 2012 #64
    Humanist_Activist Apr 2012 #67
    JoeyT Apr 2012 #138
    Mimosa Apr 2012 #160
    WiffenPoof Apr 2012 #65
    bluestateguy Apr 2012 #71
    msongs Apr 2012 #72
    Humanist_Activist Apr 2012 #78
    mistertrickster Apr 2012 #80
    Obamacare Apr 2012 #84
    TriMera Apr 2012 #81
    mistertrickster Apr 2012 #85
    Hugabear Apr 2012 #88
    mistertrickster Apr 2012 #92
    Humanist_Activist Apr 2012 #95
    Humanist_Activist Apr 2012 #90
    mistertrickster Apr 2012 #98
    Humanist_Activist Apr 2012 #101
    TriMera Apr 2012 #96
    Marrah_G Apr 2012 #135
    DirkGently Apr 2012 #82
    mistertrickster Apr 2012 #89
    whatchamacallit Apr 2012 #83
    rhett o rick Apr 2012 #86
    mistertrickster Apr 2012 #94
    Humanist_Activist Apr 2012 #99
    mistertrickster Apr 2012 #100
    sadbear Apr 2012 #102
    Humanist_Activist Apr 2012 #103
    mistertrickster Apr 2012 #105
    Humanist_Activist Apr 2012 #106
    mistertrickster Apr 2012 #108
    Humanist_Activist Apr 2012 #109
    mistertrickster Apr 2012 #128
    Humanist_Activist Apr 2012 #133
    provis99 Apr 2012 #104
    Rex Apr 2012 #107
    Humanist_Activist Apr 2012 #118
    RainDog Apr 2012 #120
    Humanist_Activist Apr 2012 #123
    RainDog Apr 2012 #129
    Humanist_Activist Apr 2012 #134
    Marrah_G Apr 2012 #136
    cherokeeprogressive Apr 2012 #124
    Hugabear Apr 2012 #125
    Warren Stupidity Apr 2012 #168
    rufus dog Apr 2012 #112
    kentauros Apr 2012 #126
    sudopod Apr 2012 #115
    Zalatix Apr 2012 #116
    mistertrickster Apr 2012 #119
    Fumesucker Apr 2012 #132
    RainDog Apr 2012 #147
    TransitJohn Apr 2012 #121
    sadbear Apr 2012 #122
    Lost-in-FL Apr 2012 #127
    mistertrickster Apr 2012 #130
    Lost-in-FL Apr 2012 #139
    Marrah_G Apr 2012 #131
    JoeyT Apr 2012 #137
    Egalitarian Thug Apr 2012 #153
    teknomanzer Apr 2012 #140
    Egalitarian Thug Apr 2012 #151
    Egalitarian Thug Apr 2012 #152
    Mimosa Apr 2012 #156
    LineReply The fact that you've trotted out this list as, presumably, slamdunk examples of "bashing", says alot
    Warren DeMontague Apr 2012 #158
    Marrah_G Apr 2012 #170
    GeorgeGist Apr 2012 #163
    GeorgeGist Apr 2012 #164
    MadHound Apr 2012 #165
    maddezmom Apr 2012 #171
    Please login to view edit histories.