Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

Showing Original Post only (View all)
 

cpwm17

(3,829 posts)
Wed Aug 13, 2014, 02:53 PM Aug 2014

If a button gave you 1 million dollars for pressing it, but killed 1 random human being in the world [View all]

would you press it? This is a thought experiment.

I would say no. I hope everyone else here would do the same.

The problem is most of our politicians say yes, because that is what they do when they vote yes on most of the pro-war resolutions passed by congress. For selfish political reasons they snuff out random lives on the other side of the world. But they murder far more than just one.

They voted to push the button when they supported Israel's atrocities in the Gaza Strip. They voted to push the button when they supported either of the Iraq Wars or the sanctions that followed the first. There are unfortunately numerous examples in US history, including many recent examples, where US politicians have voted to push the button.

Any politicians that say yes to this question should never get any votes. Many Americans seem to think that the lives of humans in parts of the world aren't worth much. And politicians', such as Hillary Clinton's, positions supporting war are simply disagreements, and we should look at some other alleged positive quality concerning their positions. No, it should be one strike and you're out for mass murder, and a visit to The Hague if there were any justice in this world.


The Twilight Zone: Season 1, Episode 50 Button, Button:


Unfortunately, there is no karma in real life
91 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
I remember that episode. n/t PowerToThePeople Aug 2014 #1
I would not push it. Ever. n/t CaliforniaPeggy Aug 2014 #2
Good answer! cpwm17 Aug 2014 #10
Dear Peggy, suppose society covered over the "random kill" so it was very hard to see... KittyWampus Aug 2014 #76
I don't think I could live with myself even if I... Little Star Aug 2014 #3
I'm broke but I'm not a killer. In_The_Wind Aug 2014 #4
Me, neither. Louisiana1976 Aug 2014 #25
I would not press that button n/t malaise Aug 2014 #5
nope, wouldn't press it nt steve2470 Aug 2014 #6
Everyone will answer no, and on DU I generally believe the answers. stevenleser Aug 2014 #7
I'm not sure I get your answer - I don't think you're being evasive, closeupready Aug 2014 #22
Hi. Yes, I may have not phrased it so clearly. stevenleser Aug 2014 #24
Agreed. And if someone else does push that button, our buttons get pushed. Keeps going on. freshwest Aug 2014 #43
Everyone on DU conveniently ignores the fact that the products they buy are made using sweat shops, KittyWampus Aug 2014 #77
That is a very tough and good point. stevenleser Aug 2014 #80
No. And I hope I would walk away from Omelas as well. nt Hekate Aug 2014 #8
Le Guin, yes? Love her stuff tkmorris Aug 2014 #33
Ursula K. Le Guin, "The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas" hunter Aug 2014 #61
No, but... Wait Wut Aug 2014 #9
Years ago I saw a poll asking this very same question. cpwm17 Aug 2014 #13
I wouldn't doubt it. Wait Wut Aug 2014 #16
I have tried to appeal to their selfish streak too. Usually they don't concede, but instead GoneFishin Aug 2014 #59
Before or after taxes? JaneyVee Aug 2014 #11
That's exactly how Dick Cheney became a millionaire. nt TeamPooka Aug 2014 #12
I can believe it. Louisiana1976 Aug 2014 #26
Speaking of Dick Cheney, do I get to pick the person? n/t A Simple Game Aug 2014 #49
But....what if that random person....was ME?!??! underpants Aug 2014 #14
oh damn! zappaman Aug 2014 #18
Hmmmm DesMoinesDem Aug 2014 #15
The guy on the left reminds me of right-wingers. cpwm17 Aug 2014 #19
Great way to frame the dilemma. closeupready Aug 2014 #17
I wouldn't do it.Couldn't live with myself if I did. SummerSnow Aug 2014 #20
A human being is worth more than a million dollars, so no way! sabrina 1 Aug 2014 #21
I'd press it multiple times, hoping it would pay off each time. Ron Obvious Aug 2014 #23
lol! Same here. Marr Aug 2014 #66
I'd hit it like a rat on crack jberryhill Aug 2014 #27
It's hard to answer truthfully because the question is hypothetical rock Aug 2014 #28
Of course not edhopper Aug 2014 #29
Nope. I would expect a macabre O'Henry twist that would have me Baitball Blogger Aug 2014 #30
Most Republicans would push the button if they didn't get any money at all. Yavin4 Aug 2014 #31
Thanks for getting some Hillary bashing in this thread... joeybee12 Aug 2014 #32
It was a Hillary post that made me think of this. cpwm17 Aug 2014 #35
See my post below...vote for you who want to... joeybee12 Aug 2014 #41
So you think pushing the meme that Democrats can't win in 2016 w/o H. Clinton-Sachs rhett o rick Aug 2014 #36
Oh FFS... joeybee12 Aug 2014 #39
FFS? Right off the bat? And then you use the idiotic meme that if you don't want H. Clinton-Sachs rhett o rick Aug 2014 #42
No, and as cynical as I can be about politics, I do not believe our politicians go to war Warren DeMontague Aug 2014 #34
They do it for selfish reasons cpwm17 Aug 2014 #38
I think those that make their fortunes from it do BrotherIvan Aug 2014 #58
Oh, I don't think they'd consciously admit to it-- even to themselves-- but I definitely think Marr Aug 2014 #68
+1 treestar Aug 2014 #73
I'd press it for $20. nt Dreamer Tatum Aug 2014 #37
do you take paypal? jberryhill Aug 2014 #65
The word "karma" is often misused. It is not revenge. Karma determines where in the chain of life rhett o rick Aug 2014 #40
the Buddhist conception of karma is just a recognition of the current moment is the result of bettyellen Aug 2014 #55
I believe the Hindu have a similar understanding of karma. The only way one can get rhett o rick Aug 2014 #63
I'd play the drum solo from YYZ on that bad boy. reflection Aug 2014 #44
I would press it (nt) bigwillq Aug 2014 #45
What if you used that million to save 1,000 lives? One life taken, 1,000 lives saved. Vattel Aug 2014 #46
Problem here is, the '1 life = $1M' is quid pro quo; closeupready Aug 2014 #48
I'm sort of dumb, but if the 'I'd press it' posts r serious, closeupready Aug 2014 #47
You make a good point Puzzledtraveller Aug 2014 #75
What would you do for a Klondike Bar? kjones Aug 2014 #50
My favorite version... Spitfire of ATJ Aug 2014 #51
I wouldn't press it to kill a random person. I might to kill an identified person. Shrike47 Aug 2014 #52
The tobacco & petroleum industries also keep pressing that button and collect their cash. SunSeeker Aug 2014 #53
the question is interesting! tomm2thumbs Aug 2014 #54
Yes, it was tough to watch. cpwm17 Aug 2014 #84
We push that button every time we pay taxes. dilby Aug 2014 #56
Made into a good movie, The Box JackRiddler Aug 2014 #57
Most of us have pushed the button. aikoaiko Aug 2014 #60
K/R. I know a Certain Someone running for POTUS who would push it, and who HAS pushed it. NYC_SKP Aug 2014 #62
I am not ready and never will. We need someone with integrity. Just sayin' nm rhett o rick Aug 2014 #64
Hillary pressed it. Only, it was a million people that died and... ChisolmTrailDem Aug 2014 #67
If it was random? No Prophet 451 Aug 2014 #69
We all push it every day with our tax money....except we don't get any $$$ in return. cbdo2007 Aug 2014 #70
We push it every day with our money spent on products made in sweat shops. KittyWampus Aug 2014 #79
Good point. So we're all essentially pushing it multiple times per day. cbdo2007 Aug 2014 #83
I'm glad you mentioned that jberryhill Aug 2014 #85
The corporate logo is like a fig leaf, I guess. KittyWampus Aug 2014 #87
no Puzzledtraveller Aug 2014 #71
I'm no warmonger, but I don't think your analogy is fair treestar Aug 2014 #72
The great majority of US military actions are not for defense. cpwm17 Aug 2014 #82
When we buy ANYTHING made in a sweatshop, we are almost certainly doing just that. KittyWampus Aug 2014 #74
and the statistical deaths from a number of sources jberryhill Aug 2014 #86
Is there a limit to how many times you can press it? Orrex Aug 2014 #78
Please don't give this button to conservatives. Kelvin Mace Aug 2014 #81
Have you not SEEN this story? alphafemale Aug 2014 #88
is it a one shot deal or can you keep pressing it? backwoodsbob Aug 2014 #89
Depends GimmeDANEger Aug 2014 #90
if only it were that simple, the buttons we push don't kill like that, they stab with a whereisjustice Aug 2014 #91
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»If a button gave you 1 mi...