Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

Showing Original Post only (View all)

Fred Sanders

(23,946 posts)
Sat Jul 19, 2014, 12:22 PM Jul 2014

Americas exceptional hypocrisy - some remember Iran Air flight 655 [View all]

Last edited Sat Jul 19, 2014, 03:14 PM - Edit history (3)

No apologies, no statement of responsibility, just excuses, America has shown how denial is done.

Nations without clean hands should not throw the first stones.

.........................

The apparent shooting down of a Malaysia Airlines flight near the Russia-Ukraine border today, being blamed on Russian-backed separatists by Kiev, is a rare occurrence of civil aviation coming up against modern missiles. The USS Vincennes incident was another. Below are two pieces from the Monitor's coverage of that tragedy at the time. The first is from shortly after the attack on July 3, 1988, the second is a follow-up on the Navy's findings a month later.

(From the July 5, 1988 Christian Science Monitor by Warren Richey)

The Iranian commercial jetliner shot down Sunday over the Strait of Hormuz followed the same flight profile established by Iranian F-14 jets in recent days, according to a reliable source in the Gulf who asks not to named.

The source says the F-14s had a routine of approaching the US cruiser Vincennes, provoking a radioed warning, and then flying off in the week before the shootdown, the source says. The information suggests that previous Iranian jetfighter activity may have contributed to the identification by the US warship of the commercial jet as a fighter.

But it leaves unresolved the major question of why officers oh the state-of-the-art cruiser Vincennes were unable to distinguish between an F-14 fighter and a large, slow, commercial Airbus.

Commercial airliners throughout the world are equipped with special transponders that automatically identify them as nonbelligerent aircraft. The Iranian Airbus’s transponder was either out of order or switched off, according to US officials. And experts say that on a radar screen an Airbus at 7,000 feet appears little different than an F-14.

In addition, radar and electronic warfare technicians on the Vincennes detected “electronic emanations" that led them to believe the plane was an F-14 fighter.

....................

Sure, they switched off the transponder in a conflict zone, sure they did. You have to say that otherwise you are a criminal for ignoring it or not caring.

"State of the art" guided missile cruiser with more electronics and detection devices than you can possibly know, but.....oopsie?

http://news.yahoo.com/monitor-archives-shooting-down-iran-air-flight-655-184749961.html

.....................

EDIT:

Because I love maps:



Party voting, by region:



......................


EDIT2:

Interesting comment I received:

On June 29th, 2014 - Russia was BRAGGING about the separatists capturing the Buk missile launcher

Google Chrome Translation:

http://rusvesna.su/news/1404041521

LIGHTNING: the sky over Donetsk - DNR commandos captured the garrison missile air defense forces

29.06.2014 - 15:32

In Donetsk, Donetsk Army Special Forces soldiers People's Republic captured the garrison of missile troops, anti-aircraft missile defense regiment number A-1402. In service parts are powerful air defense system of long-range detection and destruction of air targets.

The press service of the Interior Ministry of Ukraine in Donetsk region confirmed this information: "In Donetsk representatives" DNR "seized the military part number A-1402."

Military unit A1402 (Donetsk SAM regiment) formed in the village Alexeevka Belgorod-Dniester region Odessa region. In 2007, was made part of the redeployment of A1402 in Donetsk.

Donetsk missile regiment performs tasks for the protection of the eastern borders of the state and the protection of important industrial centers of Donbass.....

http://www.democraticunderground.com/?com=view_post&forum=1002&pid=5263031

111 replies = new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight: NoneDon't highlight anything 5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
Worth a read. Agschmid Jul 2014 #1
Indeed. There is nothing new under the sun. Fred Sanders Jul 2014 #3
LIES first ("plane off course"). Then DISGUSTING LIES (Indeed, the very SAME: "already-dead victims" WinkyDink Jul 2014 #2
Thanks for the reminder. (eom) CanSocDem Jul 2014 #4
The world needs an international Apology Act, admit your guilt, get a break,,,,, Fred Sanders Jul 2014 #5
A global truth and reconciliation conference malaise Jul 2014 #12
Fuck, that would be awesome, the line of apology makers would be endless as history. Fred Sanders Jul 2014 #13
oh for pity's sake: "nations without clean hands should not throw the first stones" cali Jul 2014 #6
Nations who throw missiles at commercial jets should not throw stones? Much better, thanks. Fred Sanders Jul 2014 #7
Yeah, but lets attempt to be honest. American hypocrisy reaches scary heights. CBGLuthier Jul 2014 #8
Dirty, dirty hands, dirty and hypocritical with a long, long list..... Fred Sanders Jul 2014 #9
+1 NealK Jul 2014 #63
I also remember Cubana 455 malaise Jul 2014 #10
Apparently being dead for 26 years means we should not consider the parallels relevant...? Fred Sanders Jul 2014 #24
The double standards are breath-taking malaise Jul 2014 #25
Lesson: Even well-trained, well-equipped militaries make mistakes. TwilightGardener Jul 2014 #11
That comes closest to my viewpoint. I think the OP is wrong-headed stevenleser Jul 2014 #18
20 years brings us to 1994 daleo Jul 2014 #23
Its a long time ago to try to deflect blame for something. nt stevenleser Jul 2014 #26
Why don't you supply us with the logical cut off date? Not that it matters anyway, I mean A Simple Game Jul 2014 #68
Who said the targeting of this Malaysian airliner was intentional? TwilightGardener Jul 2014 #86
Who said it was intentional? Half of the posts on DU say it was targeted because it was mistaken A Simple Game Jul 2014 #92
It was intentionally shot down, but I haven't seen reports or suggestions that TwilightGardener Jul 2014 #93
Supposed sins? No sense of this conversation continuing even if you could shake all of that A Simple Game Jul 2014 #94
I think StevenLeser is wrong-headed. BillZBubb Jul 2014 #79
Well said, and time passing of 20 years makes it less relevant because.......it does not. That was Fred Sanders Jul 2014 #95
I disagree Caretha Jul 2014 #98
Who gave the Syrian rebels their weapons? malaise Jul 2014 #29
Well, to be fair, Putin gives Assad a lot of backing and arms. TwilightGardener Jul 2014 #31
FFS - the West is in Syria like white on rice malaise Jul 2014 #33
I know it's painful for you, but sometimes you have to admit that the US is not the TwilightGardener Jul 2014 #35
Look there are many positives about the US malaise Jul 2014 #43
Painful to even contemplate for some, others contemplating openly is almost as bad to them. Fred Sanders Jul 2014 #45
"nothing Putin has done is in the league of what America did in Iraq" EX500rider Jul 2014 #49
We could post and counter post war pictures former9thward Jul 2014 #62
Putin is George W. Bush. Actually, Dick Cheney. I'm fine with that, I hate them both. TwilightGardener Jul 2014 #87
Yeah, Putin's a monster when it comes to Gay People and journalists who cross him.. and now he's Cha Jul 2014 #104
Putin's just a poor misunderstood asshole dictator.. It's "The West!!" you have to watch out for. nm Cha Jul 2014 #107
It's very telling, how much energy goes into defending Putin and making sure we all know TwilightGardener Jul 2014 #111
And we gave weapons to TERRROISTS in Libya, followed up on that disaster lately or is 'out of sabrina 1 Jul 2014 #102
The British had a plan to arm and train Syrian 100,000 rebels, but it was scrapped TwilightGardener Jul 2014 #110
Ok, fine bluestateguy Jul 2014 #14
Criticism is fine, just do not throw stones as if never having done exactly the same before. Fred Sanders Jul 2014 #15
I look forward to seeing your list bluestateguy Jul 2014 #20
Please explain what you mean by "throwing stones" if that does not include criticism. Coventina Jul 2014 #21
Sorry, gotta go and mow the lawn and turn over some stones....lot of rain here lately. Fred Sanders Jul 2014 #27
Of course you do! Coventina Jul 2014 #28
And who can forget the Russian shoot down of Korean Air Lines Flight 007? NutmegYankee Jul 2014 #16
Ok, seriously? Savannahmann Jul 2014 #17
America can cast the second stone, we good? And the victims of Iran Air are just as dead today as Fred Sanders Jul 2014 #19
Actually, we didn't do something similar. Our military made the mistake-- TwilightGardener Jul 2014 #40
Actually, we were not held accountable. mbperrin Jul 2014 #51
Actually, we were--it was our military that was undeniably involved, whether or not TwilightGardener Jul 2014 #55
There were no mitigating circumstances. As part of the payout, we accepted and were assigned no mbperrin Jul 2014 #58
I'm not getting your point. Did the US say "It was a planeload of dead zombie people" TwilightGardener Jul 2014 #65
Well, the Iran flight was shot down in 1988, and the court action mbperrin Jul 2014 #74
I don't think we denied we did it. The controversy seemed to be whether or not TwilightGardener Jul 2014 #84
What's the hurry? There's an 8 year timeline. mbperrin Jul 2014 #99
Your condescension aside, it doesn't take a legal genius TwilightGardener Jul 2014 #100
I wasn't being condescending at all, I was inviting you to check with a trusted source mbperrin Jul 2014 #101
Your argument is morally bankrupt. BillZBubb Jul 2014 #81
Might makes right, my father told me, and who is mightier and therefore more right than America? Fred Sanders Jul 2014 #82
That's almost as funny as "Money is Speech". BillZBubb Jul 2014 #83
Here is an interesting article about civilian plane shoot downs daleo Jul 2014 #22
IIRC, the US paid $190 million to the victim's families. n/t FSogol Jul 2014 #30
Never admitted it, no apologies.....kind of like American banks and how they pay for their crimes. Fred Sanders Jul 2014 #32
Nope, less than a third of that. mbperrin Jul 2014 #52
I'm sure this will make the families of the passengers of Flight MH17 feel so much better. conservaphobe Jul 2014 #34
Straw man alert! Fred Sanders Jul 2014 #37
Alert that you don't know what a straw man is!!!! stevenleser Jul 2014 #41
I know, right? Coventina Jul 2014 #44
Lawn was too wet and full of stones.....I digress... Fred Sanders Jul 2014 #47
Nah, he should just pay 200k to each victim's family along with mbperrin Jul 2014 #53
It's the UK's fault that Jean d Arc was burnt at the stake, so they cant prosecute anyone for murder stevenleser Jul 2014 #36
Straw man double yellow alert, mixed with red herrings. Fred Sanders Jul 2014 #38
You're just being an apologist for the UK stake burners!!!!11!11!!!!! nt stevenleser Jul 2014 #39
You do realize that it was in France, right? mbperrin Jul 2014 #54
Post removed Post removed Jul 2014 #60
That explains why he's always so "fair and balanced". NealK Jul 2014 #67
Done by the English in France. Coventina Jul 2014 #61
To be even more clear, mbperrin Jul 2014 #71
The French burned Jeanne D'Arc?... SidDithers Jul 2014 #70
What were we all talking about again? Fred Sanders Jul 2014 #72
Glad I could help. mbperrin Jul 2014 #75
Say, have you bothered to voice your disapproval of what Putin's thugs have been doing? geek tragedy Jul 2014 #42
Crickets.. Cha Jul 2014 #90
I'm surprised no one has brought up the tragedy of Korean Air Lines Flight 007.. Cha Jul 2014 #105
If I remember this correctly... perdita9 Jul 2014 #46
The guided missile cruiser was state of the art, bristling with surveillance technology...hard to Fred Sanders Jul 2014 #48
"how do Ukrainian guerrilla fighters stack up?" EX500rider Jul 2014 #50
I think the Ukrainian army has some, maybe someone stole one? Working theory only. Fred Sanders Jul 2014 #57
I remember and I knew the press would ignore it. Because if we do it, it is a "Sorry." McCamy Taylor Jul 2014 #56
That says it about as well as I have seen. mbperrin Jul 2014 #59
Did you really just say "All other countries AND TERRORIST CELLS never make a mistake"? TwilightGardener Jul 2014 #85
How would evidence Kieve air control diverted the flight path to take it over the war zone play Fred Sanders Jul 2014 #88
All information should be released, no evidence should be tampered with. TwilightGardener Jul 2014 #89
Here are some interesting maps on language and voting - East ?Ukraine in solidly Russian speaking Fred Sanders Jul 2014 #64
If you expect an apology from the US sadoldgirl Jul 2014 #66
I'm not sure what the point is. kjones Jul 2014 #69
What about the actual perpetrators? Those who are/were "just following orders"? Tierra_y_Libertad Jul 2014 #73
Yes, that would be the Self-defence forces of the Donetsk People’s Republic FrodosPet Jul 2014 #77
America got Israel's planes, tanks and weapons operational also......and given for near free. Fred Sanders Jul 2014 #78
Excellent OP Fred. Thanks so much for posting this, indeed. eom Purveyor Jul 2014 #76
The thing is I think Putin is a bad man, not a monster, but monster it must be....or else. Fred Sanders Jul 2014 #80
That's sweet you're sticking up for Putin not being a monster because first of all the Cha Jul 2014 #103
were the Germans Hypocrites for criticizing BUsh on Iraq because of their history ? JI7 Jul 2014 #91
No, Germany has fully apologized for what they have done. BillZBubb Jul 2014 #96
Rachel Maddow on this: recommended. The Russians have done this repeatedly; the US, once Hekate Jul 2014 #97
Sorry, Bad USA-Russia needs Pity.. Yeah, Rachel didn't follow that thinking last night.. she Cha Jul 2014 #106
She said of Russia's statements every time they've done this: "Here comes the crazy." Hekate Jul 2014 #108
I know how exciting that must be to realize it's RAINING when you need it so Cha Jul 2014 #109
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Americas exceptional hypo...