HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Main » General Discussion (Forum) » As a white male I am blam... » Reply #212
Introducing Discussionist: A new forum by the creators of DU

Response to Niceguy1 (Reply #201)

Wed May 14, 2014, 10:06 AM

212. Your version of unity is one that ignores an already existing divide

I wrote this in another thread.

The divide already exists.
As 1strongblackman explained in another thread. http://www.democraticunderground.com/?com=view_post&forum=1002&pid=4925485

What you don't want is to hear about the view on the other side of that divide.

Moreover, Democrats argue on every issue under the sun, from Snowden to Obamacare, Hillary Clinton, and everything else. Yet some members single out the voices of people of color and feminists to denounce as too "divisive."

First people argue Democrats all already on racism anyway. It's an already settled issue. Then you say you don't like to see Democrats divided. These arguments contradict each other. They do not hold up to scrutiny since there are scores of others subjects around which people agree and disagree that you don't object to.

This strikes me as a demonstration of entitlement: if it's not about white men, they don't think is important or legitimate. Every time someone tells people of color, feminists, and members of other subaltern groups that there concerns are illegitimate or too divisive to be discussed, they only deepen that divide you want to pretend doesn't exist.


See this on the Irish. http://www.amazon.com/Irish-Became-White-Routledge-Classics/dp/0415963095

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 304 replies Author Time Post
Harmony Blue May 13 OP
ret5hd May 13 #1
Buddyblazon May 14 #170
Scootaloo May 14 #198
Buddyblazon May 14 #204
Scootaloo May 14 #219
Jamastiene May 15 #272
Jamastiene May 15 #276
Whisp May 13 #2
BainsBane May 13 #3
nomorenomore08 May 14 #143
TheBlackAdder May 14 #250
BainsBane May 14 #252
TheBlackAdder May 14 #255
mulsh May 13 #4
Sheepshank May 13 #5
William769 May 13 #6
CANDO May 13 #33
William769 May 13 #34
LanternWaste May 13 #38
CANDO May 13 #46
tblue37 May 13 #95
laundry_queen May 14 #155
tblue37 May 14 #215
1StrongBlackMan May 14 #265
LanternWaste May 13 #7
nomorenomore08 May 14 #145
Sheldon Cooper May 13 #8
nomorenomore08 May 14 #146
BainsBane May 13 #9
AverageJoe90 May 13 #26
Feral Child May 13 #40
cyberswede May 13 #49
redqueen May 13 #50
AverageJoe90 May 13 #54
cyberswede May 13 #56
BainsBane May 13 #59
AverageJoe90 May 13 #60
cyberswede May 13 #63
AverageJoe90 May 13 #70
cyberswede May 13 #76
AverageJoe90 May 13 #79
nomorenomore08 May 14 #148
Niceguy1 May 13 #64
cyberswede May 13 #65
BainsBane May 13 #134
Niceguy1 May 14 #201
boston bean May 14 #210
LineLineLineLineLineLineLineLineLineLineReply Your version of unity is one that ignores an already existing divide
BainsBane May 14 #212
bettyellen May 14 #217
BainsBane May 13 #133
1StrongBlackMan May 14 #266
nomorenomore08 May 14 #147
CANDO May 13 #39
riqster May 13 #10
1StrongBlackMan May 15 #269
riqster May 15 #281
1StrongBlackMan May 15 #284
riqster May 15 #285
1StrongBlackMan May 15 #286
riqster May 15 #287
1StrongBlackMan May 15 #291
riqster May 15 #292
1StrongBlackMan May 15 #296
riqster May 15 #297
riqster May 16 #298
1StrongBlackMan May 16 #299
Jamastiene May 15 #273
Lex May 13 #11
riqster May 13 #30
TorchTheWitch May 13 #68
Starry Messenger May 13 #71
gollygee May 13 #72
Marrah_G May 13 #77
uponit7771 May 13 #101
JI7 May 13 #119
adigal May 13 #124
Lex May 13 #135
adigal May 14 #267
nomorenomore08 May 14 #149
Harmony Blue May 14 #205
adigal May 15 #268
Hippo_Tron May 13 #138
Nay May 13 #140
1StrongBlackMan May 15 #270
myrna minx May 13 #12
chervilant May 13 #13
NuclearDem May 13 #14
Iggo May 13 #24
wavesofeuphoria May 13 #100
hfojvt May 13 #106
nomorenomore08 May 14 #150
Ed Suspicious May 13 #15
redqueen May 13 #20
boston bean May 13 #22
bettyellen May 13 #16
stage left May 13 #17
Demo_Chris May 13 #18
Iggo May 13 #19
leftyohiolib May 13 #21
Gormy Cuss May 13 #23
boston bean May 13 #27
Eleanors38 May 13 #48
PeaceNikki May 13 #52
Gormy Cuss May 13 #61
Eleanors38 May 13 #62
boston bean May 13 #66
Eleanors38 May 13 #90
boston bean May 13 #91
nomorenomore08 May 14 #151
VanillaRhapsody May 13 #69
Eleanors38 May 13 #92
VanillaRhapsody May 13 #93
boston bean May 13 #94
Eleanors38 May 13 #136
Gormy Cuss May 13 #98
Eleanors38 May 13 #121
Eleanors38 May 14 #209
Harmony Blue May 14 #207
Eleanors38 May 14 #208
uppityperson May 13 #73
Harmony Blue May 13 #126
Gormy Cuss May 13 #130
Harmony Blue May 14 #206
Gormy Cuss May 14 #211
Harmony Blue May 14 #220
Gormy Cuss May 14 #242
nomorenomore08 May 14 #153
Harmony Blue May 14 #224
bravenak May 14 #228
myrna minx May 14 #230
bravenak May 14 #232
myrna minx May 14 #235
bravenak May 14 #236
nomorenomore08 May 14 #243
nomorenomore08 May 14 #245
bravenak May 14 #247
nomorenomore08 May 14 #248
bravenak May 14 #251
Enthusiast May 15 #278
bravenak May 15 #288
myrna minx May 14 #229
bravenak May 14 #233
uppityperson May 14 #238
gollygee May 14 #239
redqueen May 14 #240
Starry Messenger May 14 #241
redqueen May 14 #259
nomorenomore08 May 14 #244
JustAnotherGen May 14 #260
nomorenomore08 May 14 #261
JustAnotherGen May 15 #283
BainsBane May 14 #263
bettyellen May 15 #271
Jamastiene May 15 #274
Enthusiast May 15 #279
Cali_Democrat May 15 #289
Liberal_Stalwart71 May 15 #293
Whisp May 15 #295
heaven05 Jun 8 #300
bravenak Jun 8 #303
noiretextatique Jun 9 #304
laundry_queen May 14 #162
AverageJoe90 May 13 #25
LineReply .
Tuesday Afternoon May 13 #28
bravenak May 14 #152
LineLineLineReply !
Tuesday Afternoon May 14 #186
steve2470 May 13 #29
boston bean May 13 #31
nomorenomore08 May 14 #158
PeaceNikki May 13 #32
FrodosPet May 14 #163
Feral Child May 13 #35
bravenak May 13 #36
JustAnotherGen May 13 #82
McDiggy May 13 #37
PeaceNikki May 13 #41
bettyellen May 13 #43
McDiggy May 13 #67
Feral Child May 13 #45
NuclearDem May 13 #53
steve2470 May 13 #55
McDiggy May 13 #74
PeaceNikki May 13 #84
laundry_queen May 14 #165
Lex May 13 #78
Tarheel_Dem May 13 #85
PeaceNikki May 13 #87
uponit7771 May 13 #102
AverageJoe90 May 13 #103
gollygee May 13 #110
AverageJoe90 May 13 #112
gollygee May 13 #113
AverageJoe90 May 13 #116
nomorenomore08 May 14 #173
redqueen May 13 #118
nomorenomore08 May 14 #168
nomorenomore08 May 14 #160
YoungDemCA May 14 #223
Enthusiast May 15 #280
Dorian Gray May 13 #42
Ohio Joe May 13 #44
AverageJoe90 May 13 #51
nomorenomore08 May 14 #175
uponit7771 May 13 #104
PeaceNikki May 13 #47
redqueen May 13 #58
laundry_queen May 14 #167
nomorenomore08 May 14 #176
HERVEPA May 13 #57
bettyellen May 14 #218
Puzzledtraveller May 13 #75
TDale313 May 13 #80
lostincalifornia May 13 #81
Starry Messenger May 13 #83
TDale313 May 13 #86
Starry Messenger May 13 #117
nomorenomore08 May 14 #177
Enthusiast May 15 #282
TeacherB87 May 13 #88
YoungDemCA May 13 #89
ancianita May 13 #96
nomorenomore08 May 14 #178
ancianita May 14 #213
Initech May 13 #97
uponit7771 May 13 #105
raccoon May 13 #99
Zenlitened May 13 #107
nomorenomore08 May 14 #187
SaltyBro May 13 #108
Rex May 13 #109
SaltyBro May 13 #111
Name removed May 14 #156
Shandris May 13 #114
AverageJoe90 May 13 #120
nomorenomore08 May 14 #188
bravenak May 14 #190
DrewFlorida May 13 #115
joshcryer May 13 #122
nomorenomore08 May 14 #189
joshcryer May 14 #191
adigal May 13 #123
rhett o rick May 13 #125
Skittles May 14 #144
Gravitycollapse May 13 #127
Squinch May 13 #128
cyberswede May 13 #139
laundry_queen May 14 #169
redqueen May 14 #225
Squinch May 14 #237
SummerSnow May 13 #129
cherokeeprogressive May 13 #131
Jamastiene May 15 #275
kwassa May 13 #132
RedCappedBandit May 13 #137
Harmony Blue May 14 #226
RedCappedBandit May 14 #227
nomorenomore08 May 14 #262
Liberal_Stalwart71 May 15 #294
nomorenomore08 May 14 #141
Name removed May 14 #159
nomorenomore08 May 14 #161
Name removed May 14 #164
nomorenomore08 May 14 #166
Name removed May 14 #172
nomorenomore08 May 14 #179
Name removed May 14 #192
nomorenomore08 May 14 #195
FrodosPet May 14 #174
nomorenomore08 May 14 #180
FrodosPet May 14 #171
U4ikLefty May 14 #142
nomorenomore08 May 14 #181
SheilaT May 14 #154
nomorenomore08 May 14 #183
SheilaT May 14 #194
Skip Intro May 14 #157
nomorenomore08 May 14 #184
Skip Intro May 14 #185
nomorenomore08 May 14 #196
Skip Intro May 14 #197
nomorenomore08 May 14 #199
Name removed May 14 #182
Buddyblazon May 14 #193
defacto7 May 14 #200
merrily May 14 #202
Skittles May 14 #203
dawg May 14 #214
NCTraveler May 14 #216
Harmony Blue May 14 #221
YoungDemCA May 14 #222
nomorenomore08 May 14 #246
BainsBane May 14 #253
NCTraveler May 15 #290
bravenak May 14 #231
randys1 May 14 #254
bravenak May 14 #256
randys1 May 14 #257
zach.magee May 14 #234
nomorenomore08 May 14 #249
bravenak May 14 #258
BainsBane May 14 #264
BainsBane Jun 8 #301
bravenak Jun 8 #302
Jamastiene May 15 #277
Please login to view edit histories.