HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Main » General Discussion (Forum) » Bring the Guillotine Back... » Reply #86
Introducing Discussionist: A new forum by the creators of DU

Response to Scootaloo (Reply #83)

Sat May 3, 2014, 08:57 PM

86. The fact we are even discussing this

Last edited Sat May 3, 2014, 09:49 PM - Edit history (1)

demonstrates how far removed we are from standards of morality as seen by the rest of the world. I've done some research on the death penalty in Brazil, which was abolished soon after the abolition of slavery in 1888. It was used primarily for slaves who killed their masters, and 19th century jurists saw it as a stain on the reputation of Brazil as a civilized nation. That was 140 yrs ago. The US still hasn't reached that level.

The guillotine was seen as more humane at the time of the French Revolution. Its association with the Reign of Terror is not easily forgotten. Besides, who wants to pick up the heads and clean up the blood? I see no way that SCOTUS would ever approve such a method as in keeping with the 8th Amendment (which in my view the death penalty itself violates.)

People who justify the death penalty by pointing to the atrocity of the crimes of the condemned miss the point. Our penal system and forms of punishment reflect who we are as a society. Ours is among the worst in the world--one of only a handful of countries that still uses the death penalty, the highest prison population in the world, and atrocious conditions within prisons. It can hardly be a surprise that we are among the most violent societies on earth (measured through the homicide rate and our state of perpetual war) when we as a people are comfortable with state-sanctioned death. Violence begets violence, and the US has become highly adept at perpetuating it.

(Someone will come along and say violent crime rates are down. That is result of demographic factors, not because the death penalty functions as a deterrent).

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 91 replies Author Time Post
XemaSab May 2014 OP
Fred Sanders May 2014 #1
Renew Deal May 2014 #2
pscot May 2014 #4
Renew Deal May 2014 #10
mindwalker_i May 2014 #14
Nye Bevan May 2014 #16
mindwalker_i May 2014 #27
Marblehead May 2014 #76
mindwalker_i May 2014 #84
Nye Bevan May 2014 #3
CTyankee May 2014 #7
Nye Bevan May 2014 #15
CTyankee May 2014 #17
L0oniX May 2014 #50
dembotoz May 2014 #5
L0oniX May 2014 #49
arely staircase May 2014 #81
rrneck May 2014 #6
Lancero May 2014 #9
Renew Deal May 2014 #12
dionysus May 2014 #20
jmowreader May 2014 #39
dionysus May 2014 #41
rrneck May 2014 #25
CTyankee May 2014 #13
struggle4progress May 2014 #19
rrneck May 2014 #24
AnalystInParadise May 2014 #58
CTyankee May 2014 #60
Ruby the Liberal May 2014 #18
rrneck May 2014 #23
petronius May 2014 #26
Sen. Walter Sobchak May 2014 #36
davidpdx May 2014 #90
Sen. Walter Sobchak May 2014 #91
MillennialDem May 2014 #62
Charlos May 2014 #64
MillennialDem May 2014 #67
Charlos May 2014 #68
MillennialDem May 2014 #69
rrneck May 2014 #77
MillennialDem May 2014 #78
rrneck May 2014 #79
ladjf May 2014 #8
Lancero May 2014 #11
BainsBane May 2014 #21
Lancero May 2014 #28
BainsBane May 2014 #37
oldhippie May 2014 #54
Trajan May 2014 #80
Scootaloo May 2014 #83
LineLineLineLineNew Reply The fact we are even discussing this
BainsBane May 2014 #86
Scootaloo May 2014 #89
nadinbrzezinski May 2014 #55
Prophet 451 May 2014 #22
TreasonousBastard May 2014 #29
NightWatcher May 2014 #31
CTyankee May 2014 #61
Historic NY May 2014 #85
MillennialDem May 2014 #63
TreasonousBastard May 2014 #70
MillennialDem May 2014 #74
geomon666 May 2014 #30
Major Nikon May 2014 #33
L0oniX May 2014 #48
pipi_k May 2014 #52
dpbrown May 2014 #32
L0oniX May 2014 #47
snot May 2014 #34
dionysus May 2014 #43
snot May 2014 #45
krispos42 May 2014 #35
BainsBane May 2014 #38
jmowreader May 2014 #40
Recursion May 2014 #42
MillennialDem May 2014 #65
BainsBane May 2014 #71
MillennialDem May 2014 #72
Shandris May 2014 #44
L0oniX May 2014 #46
Shandris May 2014 #57
Bluenorthwest May 2014 #51
pipi_k May 2014 #53
rock May 2014 #56
pipi_k May 2014 #59
PeteSelman May 2014 #66
spanone May 2014 #73
avebury May 2014 #75
Iggo May 2014 #82
Owl May 2014 #87
IDemo May 2014 #88
Please login to view edit histories.