Reply #22

In the discussion thread: Supreme Court poised to strike down PPACA [View all]

Tue Mar 27, 2012, 02:47 PM

22. So, after hearing the oral arguments

on the individual mandate, do you still think it's even remotely possible that Kennedy and Scalia are inclined to uphold the PPACA?

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum

Replies to this discussion thread

30 replies	Author	Time	Post
Supreme Court poised to strike down PPACA [View all]	Alcibiades	Mar 2012	OP
Actually,	ProSense	Mar 2012	#1
Thanks, Pro.	elleng	Mar 2012	#3
That is just wishful thinking and everyone here is clutching to it as fact	joeglow3	Mar 2012	#29
It is the studied opinion of 2 experts,	elleng	Mar 2012	#30
I hope you're right	Alcibiades	Mar 2012	#4
Try understanding how they approach making decisions,	elleng	Mar 2012	#2
I understand quite well	Alcibiades	Mar 2012	#5
I'm an attorney,	elleng	Mar 2012	#7
Students of judicial politics	Alcibiades	Mar 2012	#18
Who are the 6 votes to uphold?	Owlet	Mar 2012	#6
Breyer, Ginsburg, Kagan, Sotomayor, Kennedy, Scalia.	elleng	Mar 2012	#8
I think you're right	jehop61	Mar 2012	#9
And he upheld an important principle here,	elleng	Mar 2012	#10
I'm certainy no constitutional scholar	Owlet	Mar 2012	#11
Underlying assumption doesn't work,	elleng	Mar 2012	#12
Wouldn't Roberts be likely to side with the majority to protect "his"court from claims of excessive	Rowdyboy	Mar 2012	#13
Possible; was listing mandatory and likely minimum.	elleng	Mar 2012	#14
So, after hearing the oral arguments	Alcibiades	Mar 2012	#22
'AFTER hearing the oral arguments?'	elleng	Mar 2012	#23
This message was self-deleted by its author	Alcibiades	Mar 2012	#24
The oral arguments on the individual mandate	Alcibiades	Mar 2012	#25
Yes, and it takes a while to listen to them, doesn't it?	elleng	Mar 2012	#26
Here's an exerpt:	Alcibiades	Mar 2012	#28
It was written by the insurance companies and intended to fail.	JDPriestly	Mar 2012	#15
The mandate was a planned bonanza for the one percent,	woo me with science	Mar 2012	#16
Why would they strike it down when it saved Big Insurance who were about to go bankrupt?	sabrina 1	Mar 2012	#17
Because Rmoney says it's unconstitutional	Alcibiades	Mar 2012	#19
I disagree. It's laughable for Romney to trash a bill that is so similar to the one he	sabrina 1	Mar 2012	#20
What they want is for the Republicans to win	Alcibiades	Mar 2012	#21
Medicare For All	kenny blankenship	Mar 2012	#27

Edit History

Please login to view edit histories.