"And the current tax structure really has nothing to do with it. You can cut taxes in a way that primarily benefits the bottom (and even Obama did that ONCE with the making work pay credit, which he then quickly abandoned) or you can cut taxes in a way that primarily benefits rich people. "
Your argument ignores the current tax structure. You now want to compare apples to oranges. The OP is based on the current tax structure, but your spin ignores that.
The Making Work Pay tax credit, which was part of the stimulus, has nothing to do with the OP.