HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Main » General Discussion (Forum) » That was pretty goddamned... » Reply #172
Introducing Discussionist: A new forum by the creators of DU

Response to WilliamPitt (Original post)

Tue Sep 10, 2013, 10:21 PM

172. I've sat through it twice, and it was poorly done.

First the logic. Estimates are that more than 100,000 are dead from the Civil War. We've seen videos of Executions, and brutalities for the entire civil war. But somehow, 1,400 dead from Chemical Weapons are the only thing that matters. Now, I'm no Mathematician, but by my calculations, roughly 1 in 71 dead have died from suspected CW attacks. So 1.4 % of those dead are from suspected CW attacks. And I'm not supposed to really concern myself with the dead adults from CW attacks, but the Children, the children are what Assad must answer for.

To my friends on the left, I ask you to reconcile your belief in freedom and dignity for all people with those images of children writhing in pain and going still on a cold hospital floor, for sometimes resolutions and statements of condemnation are simply not enough.

Indeed, I'd ask every member of Congress, and those of you watching at home tonight, to view those videos of the attack, and then ask: What kind of world will we live in if the United States of America sees a dictator brazenly violate international law with poison gas and we choose to look the other way?


http://nbcpolitics.nbcnews.com/_news/2013/09/10/20427421-full-transcript-of-president-obamas-remarks-on-syria?lite

So I'm supposed to ignore 98,600 deaths because those were proper deaths. Death from shrapnel, and shock from explosives is fine, even it is children being bombed. Deaths from machete's in far away lands is no skin off our nose, even if children are hacked to death, that's an acceptable death. Death from starvation is just fine, because when you're starving you're too weak to writhe on the ground and nobody has videotaped that. Oh and bullets are the best way to die, because bleeding out is a perfectly acceptable way to be taken into the next life. No parent has ever held a child who was shot and beg them to live.

That was asinine, and it was childish, and it was even worse than amateur.

Look Mr. President. Let's be honest here. Syria is not in violation of international law, because they did not sign the CW treaty. You can't hold me responsible for a credit slip I didn't sign. Nobody does that. But you are claiming a violation of international law based upon a treaty that Syria hasn't signed. Will you allow yourself to be held accountable for landmines which are banned by nearly every other country but we haven't signed it? No of course not. That would be silly. But that is the standard you are trying to hold Syria to.

The even worse was the stretching of the imagination to the breaking point in trying to explain how this was a necessary action for the American National Security. I write fiction, and in creating a story you have to make it believable enough to suspend disbelief. Mr. President, you failed to get me to suspend disbelief on that one.

In 2011, 32,367 deaths occurred on our highway. Many of those people writhed as they died, it's a terrible thing to watch someone die, because only in Hollywood is it clean as they bravely stare off to space. Should I be more upset if 1.4% of those people died in Fiat's than if they had died in Ford's? Are Ford deaths any more dignified than deaths in some other kind of car?

That is what we are reduced to debating Mr. President. That the deaths by Gas that affected 1.4% of those killed in this war are somehow more offensive than the 98,600 who died by bombs, bullets, bladed weapons, gang rapes, bludgeoning.

You can't promise that no retaliation is going to happen. Russia has a Naval Base there. Unless Putin has assured you in writing that no retaliation will come from them, and even then I'd be suspicious, especially with all the Naval Deployments Russia has to the region, you can't promise no retaliations.

Three million Syrians are living in refugee camps, but that's fine too, because starvation and disease in a refugee camp is a proper death that is morally acceptable to the worlds oldest constitutional democracy. Asinine.

From amateur to ridiculous. This speech had it all. I love the Democratic Party, but I'm supporting other Democrats for this one gang.

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 536 replies Author Time Post
WilliamPitt Sep 2013 OP
PrestonLocke Sep 2013 #1
reformist2 Sep 2013 #372
MNBrewer Sep 2013 #385
Safetykitten Sep 2013 #2
JoePhilly Sep 2013 #3
joshcryer Sep 2013 #18
JoePhilly Sep 2013 #27
joshcryer Sep 2013 #37
former9thward Sep 2013 #50
joshcryer Sep 2013 #63
Mr.Bill Sep 2013 #92
davidwparker Sep 2013 #288
bananas Sep 2013 #369
former9thward Sep 2013 #97
joshcryer Sep 2013 #108
former9thward Sep 2013 #121
joshcryer Sep 2013 #143
former9thward Sep 2013 #210
joshcryer Sep 2013 #214
former9thward Sep 2013 #423
joshcryer Sep 2013 #510
former9thward Sep 2013 #520
Hekate Sep 2013 #237
former9thward Sep 2013 #420
cali Sep 2013 #394
heaven05 Sep 2013 #411
dionysus Sep 2013 #422
former9thward Sep 2013 #425
dionysus Sep 2013 #427
cali Sep 2013 #435
former9thward Sep 2013 #424
CherokeeDem Sep 2013 #405
former9thward Sep 2013 #426
CherokeeDem Sep 2013 #439
former9thward Sep 2013 #443
CherokeeDem Sep 2013 #451
former9thward Sep 2013 #456
CherokeeDem Sep 2013 #462
Gothmog Sep 2013 #449
felix_numinous Sep 2013 #499
Smarmie Doofus Sep 2013 #138
joshcryer Sep 2013 #153
Cheviteau Sep 2013 #403
YOHABLO Sep 2013 #232
HooptieWagon Sep 2013 #249
RC Sep 2013 #252
joshcryer Sep 2013 #272
RC Sep 2013 #280
Blanks Sep 2013 #389
RC Sep 2013 #407
Blanks Sep 2013 #438
bvar22 Sep 2013 #452
Skittles Sep 2013 #344
joshcryer Sep 2013 #345
Skittles Sep 2013 #346
joshcryer Sep 2013 #347
Skittles Sep 2013 #348
joshcryer Sep 2013 #349
Skittles Sep 2013 #350
MADem Sep 2013 #442
Comrade Grumpy Sep 2013 #460
joshcryer Sep 2013 #509
RainDog Sep 2013 #80
JoePhilly Sep 2013 #86
former9thward Sep 2013 #104
JoePhilly Sep 2013 #117
former9thward Sep 2013 #128
MADem Sep 2013 #445
joshcryer Sep 2013 #122
former9thward Sep 2013 #136
joshcryer Sep 2013 #162
Llewlladdwr Sep 2013 #178
joshcryer Sep 2013 #185
Llewlladdwr Sep 2013 #197
joshcryer Sep 2013 #200
Llewlladdwr Sep 2013 #216
mimi85 Sep 2013 #269
VanillaRhapsody Sep 2013 #106
former9thward Sep 2013 #191
VanillaRhapsody Sep 2013 #198
former9thward Sep 2013 #204
VanillaRhapsody Sep 2013 #207
former9thward Sep 2013 #212
mimi85 Sep 2013 #279
CAG Sep 2013 #192
joshcryer Sep 2013 #195
George II Sep 2013 #231
Ferretherder Sep 2013 #294
mac56 Sep 2013 #410
Ferretherder Sep 2013 #504
cynzke Sep 2013 #458
Ferretherder Sep 2013 #505
LukeFL Sep 2013 #43
U4ikLefty Sep 2013 #66
Jamastiene Sep 2013 #170
WorseBeforeBetter Sep 2013 #413
LukeFL Sep 2013 #519
msanthrope Sep 2013 #76
JoePhilly Sep 2013 #96
msanthrope Sep 2013 #101
Llewlladdwr Sep 2013 #87
msanthrope Sep 2013 #111
Llewlladdwr Sep 2013 #139
msanthrope Sep 2013 #149
Llewlladdwr Sep 2013 #156
msanthrope Sep 2013 #164
Llewlladdwr Sep 2013 #169
Hekate Sep 2013 #234
gtar100 Sep 2013 #365
LukeFL Sep 2013 #35
Hell Hath No Fury Sep 2013 #42
JoePhilly Sep 2013 #58
Hell Hath No Fury Sep 2013 #114
DirkGently Sep 2013 #160
Beer Swiller Sep 2013 #227
brush Sep 2013 #395
somethingshiny Sep 2013 #415
MADem Sep 2013 #213
DirkGently Sep 2013 #118
Hell Hath No Fury Sep 2013 #152
brush Sep 2013 #391
MADem Sep 2013 #64
AgingAmerican Sep 2013 #475
MADem Sep 2013 #477
AgingAmerican Sep 2013 #485
MADem Sep 2013 #521
AgingAmerican Sep 2013 #522
MADem Sep 2013 #523
AgingAmerican Sep 2013 #524
MADem Sep 2013 #525
AgingAmerican Sep 2013 #527
MADem Sep 2013 #528
AgingAmerican Sep 2013 #529
MADem Sep 2013 #530
AgingAmerican Sep 2013 #532
MADem Sep 2013 #533
AgingAmerican Sep 2013 #534
MADem Sep 2013 #535
AgingAmerican Sep 2013 #536
graywarrior Sep 2013 #109
mountain grammy Sep 2013 #133
Hekate Sep 2013 #229
Beer Swiller Sep 2013 #262
Carolina Sep 2013 #296
Name removed Sep 2013 #490
beerandjesus Sep 2013 #390
Number23 Sep 2013 #432
Name removed Sep 2013 #489
Number23 Sep 2013 #495
arewenotdemo Sep 2013 #440
grahamhgreen Sep 2013 #270
awoke_in_2003 Sep 2013 #466
The Link Sep 2013 #4
Awknid Sep 2013 #48
truedelphi Sep 2013 #243
quinnox Sep 2013 #5
winter is coming Sep 2013 #6
Crimson76 Sep 2013 #7
trueblue2007 Sep 2013 #8
Hell Hath No Fury Sep 2013 #45
Luminous Animal Sep 2013 #46
Politicalboi Sep 2013 #69
golfguru Sep 2013 #266
Democracyinkind Sep 2013 #363
golfguru Sep 2013 #448
jsr Sep 2013 #293
Cali_Democrat Sep 2013 #9
JoePhilly Sep 2013 #34
former9thward Sep 2013 #61
JoePhilly Sep 2013 #72
former9thward Sep 2013 #98
JoePhilly Sep 2013 #127
former9thward Sep 2013 #132
dbackjon Sep 2013 #258
former9thward Sep 2013 #418
MADem Sep 2013 #159
ConcernedCanuk Sep 2013 #357
mythology Sep 2013 #242
MADem Sep 2013 #267
former9thward Sep 2013 #417
Eko Sep 2013 #103
JoePhilly Sep 2013 #130
DJ13 Sep 2013 #115
JoePhilly Sep 2013 #125
DJ13 Sep 2013 #173
Proud Liberal Dem Sep 2013 #201
DJ13 Sep 2013 #206
Proud Liberal Dem Sep 2013 #377
Llewlladdwr Sep 2013 #39
LukeFL Sep 2013 #49
Llewlladdwr Sep 2013 #59
LukeFL Sep 2013 #67
Llewlladdwr Sep 2013 #102
U4ikLefty Sep 2013 #77
MADem Sep 2013 #189
freshwest Sep 2013 #455
MADem Sep 2013 #457
freshwest Sep 2013 #459
iandhr Sep 2013 #93
LukeFL Sep 2013 #180
freshwest Sep 2013 #479
Jackpine Radical Sep 2013 #54
suffragette Sep 2013 #90
sarcasmo Sep 2013 #268
Cal Carpenter Sep 2013 #140
DisgustipatedinCA Sep 2013 #292
laundry_queen Sep 2013 #326
cali Sep 2013 #396
NuclearDem Sep 2013 #182
Carolina Sep 2013 #264
DisgustipatedinCA Sep 2013 #297
CountAllVotes Sep 2013 #433
burnsei sensei Sep 2013 #484
Tiredofthesame Sep 2013 #211
Peace Patriot Sep 2013 #218
arewenotdemo Sep 2013 #450
freshwest Sep 2013 #290
snagglepuss Sep 2013 #441
freshwest Sep 2013 #470
morningfog Sep 2013 #313
Cali_Democrat Sep 2013 #327
beerandjesus Sep 2013 #393
noiretextatique Sep 2013 #488
forestpath Sep 2013 #10
NightWatcher Sep 2013 #11
winter is coming Sep 2013 #60
whatchamacallit Sep 2013 #12
truedelphi Sep 2013 #245
tom_kelly Sep 2013 #13
Bjorn Against Sep 2013 #14
joshcryer Sep 2013 #15
NYC_SKP Sep 2013 #16
freshwest Sep 2013 #472
struggle4progress Sep 2013 #17
joshcryer Sep 2013 #23
cigsandcoffee Sep 2013 #19
DirkGently Sep 2013 #20
winter is coming Sep 2013 #26
1awake Sep 2013 #123
DirkGently Sep 2013 #135
1awake Sep 2013 #150
Logical Sep 2013 #220
grahamhgreen Sep 2013 #273
jsr Sep 2013 #304
avaistheone1 Sep 2013 #319
snagglepuss Sep 2013 #444
merbex Sep 2013 #21
quaker bill Sep 2013 #166
jessie04 Sep 2013 #22
HangOnKids Sep 2013 #311
In_The_Wind Sep 2013 #24
Arkansas Granny Sep 2013 #25
Skidmore Sep 2013 #28
Whisp Sep 2013 #29
freshwest Sep 2013 #474
Whisp Sep 2013 #476
RebelOne Sep 2013 #30
Avalux Sep 2013 #31
snappyturtle Sep 2013 #53
DevonRex Sep 2013 #32
DisgustipatedinCA Sep 2013 #305
DevonRex Sep 2013 #310
DisgustipatedinCA Sep 2013 #316
DevonRex Sep 2013 #322
tallahasseedem Sep 2013 #421
Motown_Johnny Sep 2013 #33
bluestate10 Sep 2013 #506
johnd83 Sep 2013 #36
bluestate10 Sep 2013 #507
LukeFL Sep 2013 #38
Junkdrawer Sep 2013 #40
jazzimov Sep 2013 #41
phleshdef Sep 2013 #44
VanillaRhapsody Sep 2013 #190
Laura PourMeADrink Sep 2013 #511
VanillaRhapsody Sep 2013 #512
Laura PourMeADrink Sep 2013 #513
VanillaRhapsody Sep 2013 #517
BlueStreak Sep 2013 #47
VanillaRhapsody Sep 2013 #193
BlueStreak Sep 2013 #221
VanillaRhapsody Sep 2013 #223
BlueStreak Sep 2013 #238
VanillaRhapsody Sep 2013 #244
BlueStreak Sep 2013 #257
VanillaRhapsody Sep 2013 #263
bigtree Sep 2013 #51
Darkhawk32 Sep 2013 #52
NoOneMan Sep 2013 #55
davidpdx Sep 2013 #158
Shampoobra Sep 2013 #56
otohara Sep 2013 #94
Shampoobra Sep 2013 #199
otohara Sep 2013 #224
Shampoobra Sep 2013 #255
Hekate Sep 2013 #228
otohara Sep 2013 #265
Enthusiast Sep 2013 #341
Snake Plissken Sep 2013 #57
forestpath Sep 2013 #75
RKP5637 Sep 2013 #202
harun Sep 2013 #217
CountAllVotes Sep 2013 #431
MADem Sep 2013 #62
ProSense Sep 2013 #68
MADem Sep 2013 #112
WilliamPitt Sep 2013 #79
MADem Sep 2013 #119
ProSense Sep 2013 #157
MADem Sep 2013 #171
Whisp Sep 2013 #253
4bucksagallon Sep 2013 #331
Summer Hathaway Sep 2013 #353
4bucksagallon Sep 2013 #356
Summer Hathaway Sep 2013 #358
4bucksagallon Sep 2013 #366
Raine1967 Sep 2013 #388
Summer Hathaway Sep 2013 #482
Hekate Sep 2013 #531
Number23 Sep 2013 #434
Summer Hathaway Sep 2013 #483
bravenak Sep 2013 #65
Snake Plissken Sep 2013 #81
bravenak Sep 2013 #126
Snake Plissken Sep 2013 #161
bravenak Sep 2013 #179
Snake Plissken Sep 2013 #196
MADem Sep 2013 #256
Snake Plissken Sep 2013 #274
MADem Sep 2013 #286
freshwest Sep 2013 #518
Whisp Sep 2013 #70
MADem Sep 2013 #124
orenbus Sep 2013 #155
Hekate Sep 2013 #278
Dash87 Sep 2013 #409
DisgustipatedinCA Sep 2013 #308
Dash87 Sep 2013 #408
alcibiades_mystery Sep 2013 #284
nashville_brook Sep 2013 #71
KoKo Sep 2013 #73
msanthrope Sep 2013 #83
U4ikLefty Sep 2013 #88
msanthrope Sep 2013 #95
Whisp Sep 2013 #146
arewenotdemo Sep 2013 #454
quaker bill Sep 2013 #74
Avalux Sep 2013 #89
truedelphi Sep 2013 #240
MADem Sep 2013 #145
quaker bill Sep 2013 #181
JohnnyLib2 Sep 2013 #154
msanthrope Sep 2013 #205
FSogol Sep 2013 #376
Hekate Sep 2013 #271
Number23 Sep 2013 #436
iandhr Sep 2013 #78
bhikkhu Sep 2013 #82
struggle4progress Sep 2013 #131
noamnety Sep 2013 #84
winter is coming Sep 2013 #137
truedelphi Sep 2013 #248
noamnety Sep 2013 #370
truedelphi Sep 2013 #493
Tikki Sep 2013 #85
Beaverhausen Sep 2013 #91
grahamhgreen Sep 2013 #99
Mr.Bill Sep 2013 #100
tsuki Sep 2013 #105
Little Star Sep 2013 #107
Old and In the Way Sep 2013 #110
MADem Sep 2013 #184
Generic Other Sep 2013 #113
winter is coming Sep 2013 #142
Generic Other Sep 2013 #188
Carolina Sep 2013 #287
rury Sep 2013 #116
BlueCheese Sep 2013 #120
1awake Sep 2013 #129
Snake Plissken Sep 2013 #134
rsmith6621 Sep 2013 #141
quaker bill Sep 2013 #194
Tiredofthesame Sep 2013 #226
4bucksagallon Sep 2013 #144
Purveyor Sep 2013 #147
another_liberal Sep 2013 #148
Jamastiene Sep 2013 #151
King_Klonopin Sep 2013 #359
LittleBlue Sep 2013 #163
truedelphi Sep 2013 #254
LittleBlue Sep 2013 #260
chillfactor Sep 2013 #165
Rain Mcloud Sep 2013 #167
erpowers Sep 2013 #168
LineReply I've sat through it twice, and it was poorly done.
Savannahmann Sep 2013 #172
GeorgeGist Sep 2013 #208
woo me with science Sep 2013 #219
arewenotdemo Sep 2013 #461
russspeakeasy Sep 2013 #235
Carolina Sep 2013 #291
haikugal Sep 2013 #330
laundry_queen Sep 2013 #337
truedelphi Sep 2013 #352
Maedhros Sep 2013 #486
truedelphi Sep 2013 #492
Maedhros Sep 2013 #494
Celefin Sep 2013 #361
beerandjesus Sep 2013 #397
Supersedeas Sep 2013 #464
sibelian Sep 2013 #481
crim son Sep 2013 #174
newfie11 Sep 2013 #175
madamesilverspurs Sep 2013 #176
Whisp Sep 2013 #177
Marrah_G Sep 2013 #183
JaneyVee Sep 2013 #186
Whisp Sep 2013 #187
arewenotdemo Sep 2013 #463
Summer Hathaway Sep 2013 #203
fadedrose Sep 2013 #209
Laura PourMeADrink Sep 2013 #215
Doctor_J Sep 2013 #225
Laura PourMeADrink Sep 2013 #282
iamthebandfanman Sep 2013 #355
Doctor_J Sep 2013 #381
eridani Sep 2013 #360
carolinayellowdog Sep 2013 #222
LuckyTheDog Sep 2013 #230
dkf Sep 2013 #233
kentuck Sep 2013 #236
mrchips Sep 2013 #239
wisteria Sep 2013 #247
truedelphi Sep 2013 #261
HangOnKids Sep 2013 #317
jsr Sep 2013 #301
scheming daemons Sep 2013 #314
Bluenorthwest Sep 2013 #416
Skittles Sep 2013 #324
Democracyinkind Sep 2013 #364
Hekate Sep 2013 #241
The Midway Rebel Sep 2013 #246
arewenotdemo Sep 2013 #467
Ocelot Sep 2013 #250
wisteria Sep 2013 #251
dbackjon Sep 2013 #259
KamaAina Sep 2013 #275
Mellow Drama Sep 2013 #276
cliffordu Sep 2013 #277
obxhead Sep 2013 #281
woo me with science Sep 2013 #298
arewenotdemo Sep 2013 #471
L0oniX Sep 2013 #283
davidwparker Sep 2013 #285
Darkhawk32 Sep 2013 #300
jsr Sep 2013 #289
pnwmom Sep 2013 #295
zwyziec Sep 2013 #299
sigmasix Sep 2013 #302
nadinbrzezinski Sep 2013 #303
markpkessinger Sep 2013 #306
Summer Hathaway Sep 2013 #325
markpkessinger Sep 2013 #328
Summer Hathaway Sep 2013 #332
markpkessinger Sep 2013 #333
markpkessinger Sep 2013 #334
Summer Hathaway Sep 2013 #335
markpkessinger Sep 2013 #336
Summer Hathaway Sep 2013 #340
Summer Hathaway Sep 2013 #339
adirondacker Sep 2013 #329
beerandjesus Sep 2013 #398
MrMickeysMom Sep 2013 #307
TwilightGardener Sep 2013 #309
avaistheone1 Sep 2013 #318
scheming daemons Sep 2013 #312
Waiting For Everyman Sep 2013 #315
avaistheone1 Sep 2013 #320
BootinUp Sep 2013 #321
kardonb Sep 2013 #323
Lint Head Sep 2013 #338
polly7 Sep 2013 #342
Bolo Boffin Sep 2013 #343
SunSeeker Sep 2013 #351
iamthebandfanman Sep 2013 #354
gtar100 Sep 2013 #362
G_j Sep 2013 #379
Roland99 Sep 2013 #387
TomClash Sep 2013 #367
rucky Sep 2013 #368
michigandem58 Sep 2013 #371
DCBob Sep 2013 #373
backscatter712 Sep 2013 #374
6000eliot Sep 2013 #375
Nightjock Sep 2013 #378
Lee-Lee Sep 2013 #380
99Forever Sep 2013 #382
TBF Sep 2013 #383
Nitram Sep 2013 #384
Roland99 Sep 2013 #386
Fuddnik Sep 2013 #392
jsr Sep 2013 #402
rtracey Sep 2013 #399
beerandjesus Sep 2013 #400
Fuddnik Sep 2013 #401
LWolf Sep 2013 #404
No DUplicitous DUpe Sep 2013 #480
stonecutter357 Sep 2013 #406
Autumn Sep 2013 #412
stonecutter357 Sep 2013 #465
Autumn Sep 2013 #468
ProSense Sep 2013 #414
randome Sep 2013 #419
dionysus Sep 2013 #428
goatmilker Sep 2013 #429
CountAllVotes Sep 2013 #430
Orsino Sep 2013 #437
snagglepuss Sep 2013 #446
Jester Messiah Sep 2013 #447
bvar22 Sep 2013 #453
FiveGoodMen Sep 2013 #473
glowing Sep 2013 #469
indepat Sep 2013 #478
MineralMan Sep 2013 #487
marble falls Sep 2013 #491
Tx4obama Sep 2013 #496
Skittles Sep 2013 #497
sulphurdunn Sep 2013 #498
Catherina Sep 2013 #500
malthaussen Sep 2013 #501
kentuck Sep 2013 #502
Laura PourMeADrink Sep 2013 #515
michigandem58 Sep 2013 #503
Whisp Sep 2013 #508
Laura PourMeADrink Sep 2013 #514
gulliver Sep 2013 #516
Rex Sep 2013 #526
Please login to view edit histories.