Response to flamingdem (Original post)
Fri Jul 19, 2013, 10:10 AM
ProSense (116,461 posts)
In a few days, perhaps even tomorrow, the charms and dangers of the city will be available to Edward Snowden, who is about to receive a refugee ID, allowing him to roam freely the whole length and breadth of Russia and to socialise with its folk.
According to the piece below, Assange doesn't enjoy "refugee" status. Snowden would not be considered a "refugee." Makes sense, as it's likely why he can't leave the embassy.
Is Edward Snowden Protected By International Law?
The Huffington Post | By Carlo Davis
The Venezuelan asylum offer resembles the diplomatic asylum Ecuador granted to WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange, who has been living in the Ecuadorian embassy in London since June 2012....While Ecuador recognizes Assange as an asylum seeker, it did not give the WikiLeaks founder refugee status. Snowden's Venezuelan offer makes the same distinction. This is important, because if Snowden's Venezuelan asylum fell under UN refugee status, other signatories of the 1951 Convention would be bound, at the very least, not to return Snowden to the United States. That is not the case for asylum seekers.
In addition, if Edward Snowden wants the same protection Assange enjoys, limited though it is, he will have to get himself to Venezuela or one of its embassies or consulates.
Snowden's lawyer announced on Tuesday that Snowden applied for temporary asylum in Russia. According to Professor Saul, the approval of temporary asylum could garner Snowden the travel documents necessary to fly to other countries, including Venezuela.
Even if Snowden can get a valid travel document, however, he may still have difficulty reaching Caracas. International law does not require countries to grant safe passage to domestic asylum candidates, and Spain, France and Portugal have already indicated they may refuse Snowden access to their airspace.
- more -
Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
|sabrina 1||Jul 2013||#15|
|sabrina 1||Jul 2013||#23|
|sabrina 1||Jul 2013||#24|
|Major Hogwash||Jul 2013||#30|
Please login to view edit histories.