Welcome to DU!
The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards.
Join the community:
Create a free account
Support DU (and get rid of ads!):
Become a Star Member
Latest Breaking News
General Discussion
The DU Lounge
All Forums
Issue Forums
Culture Forums
Alliance Forums
Region Forums
Support Forums
Help & Search
General Discussion
In reply to the discussion: Fla. mom gets 20 years for firing warning shots [View all]Skeeter Barnes
(994 posts)14. People see the good guys in movies fire warning shots so they think its a good idea.
It's reckless discharge of a firearm and it's illegal. If you are being attacked, fire at the attacker if you fear grave bodily harm. If you are not in fear for your life, don't pull the trigger. IIRC, she fired two shots. That's two fewer rounds available to her if she actually did need to stop the guy.
More recently, Case Nine took place in the Southeast. A young man was violently attacked in a drivewayas he tried to exit the scene, and when the side window of his car was smashed in by one of his multiple assailants, he came up with a .38 and fired, stopping the attacker, who died from the gunfire. As he backed into the street, he fired again into the air. He said later that he did so to keep them from harming him. That single bullet, intentionally fired upward, buried itself harmlessly in a building. A skilled defense lawyer won him an acquittal on the grounds of self-defense for the fatal shooting itself, but the jury found him guilty of the lesser included offense of recklessly firing that last shot, and he wound up serving hard time with a criminal conviction on the record for the rest of his life.
The bottom line is, there are good reasons why police are forbidden to fire warning shots, and why wise armed citizens dont put the warning shot in their repertoire of defensive responses. Be able to explain why you didnt fire a warning shot and share with those who seek your advice why they shouldnt fire one, either.
The bottom line is, there are good reasons why police are forbidden to fire warning shots, and why wise armed citizens dont put the warning shot in their repertoire of defensive responses. Be able to explain why you didnt fire a warning shot and share with those who seek your advice why they shouldnt fire one, either.
http://www.tactical-life.com/combat-handguns/warning-shot-misconceptions/
20 years in prison is insane, though. There needs to be some way for judges to show some leniency. She wasn't in trouble before and this was a threatening situation for sure.
Edit history
Please sign in to view edit histories.
60 replies
= new reply since forum marked as read
Highlight:
NoneDon't highlight anything
5 newestHighlight 5 most recent replies
RecommendedHighlight replies with 5 or more recommendations
But if she was white to begin with, I believe she would have never needed to hire....
left on green only
Jul 2013
#58
It has more to do with class than race. The woman was likely represented by a public defender.
bluestate10
Jul 2013
#18
If a reasonable person in her position would fear imminent grievous bodily harm or death, then yes.
X_Digger
Jul 2013
#35
Err.. she wasn't living there at the time. You really don't know the details of this case, do you?
X_Digger
Jul 2013
#44
She got 20 years and she did even kill anybody! Did you hear about this, GZ jurors?
TheDebbieDee
Jul 2013
#8
People do not understand what self-defense means in domestic violence cases
GiaGiovanni
Jul 2013
#11
Zimmerman left the safety of his SUV and pursued Martin. I don't get your point,
bluestate10
Jul 2013
#17
If you make these kinds of claims, you need to provide links to credible sources
GiaGiovanni
Jul 2013
#48
Thank you. This definitely puts a different picture on the series of events.
GiaGiovanni
Jul 2013
#53
People see the good guys in movies fire warning shots so they think its a good idea.
Skeeter Barnes
Jul 2013
#14
Laws should be the other way around. The law, as you stated it, promotes killing
bluestate10
Jul 2013
#16
On the contrary, it promotes shooting only in self defense to protect innocent lives.
Skeeter Barnes
Jul 2013
#24
If she'd been carrying the gun, but fired warning shots, she'd be in the same place. n/t
X_Digger
Jul 2013
#37
I watched angela corey smiling like she had won last night, now i understand
DeschutesRiver
Jul 2013
#28
If you have political aspirations in Florida you must appeal to the Saltine-
msanthrope
Jul 2013
#29
Marissa Alexander was not living in the house at the time of the incident, her husband was
Lurks Often
Jul 2013
#40