HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Main » General Discussion (Forum) » Trayvon Martin was shot a... » Reply #126

Reply #126


Response to grantcart (Reply #124)

Sun Jul 7, 2013, 01:34 PM

126. it was the prosecution who convinced me.

(This may be wordier than you requested..)

(edited ----> to correct the name: I've been posting
that it was John Guy but it was Richard Mantei, asst da.
John Guy did the opening statement for the
prosecution. Both VERY good.)
.............

The ADA Richard Mantei, in appealing to the
judge not to dismiss the case, made such a
powerful presentation of the facts, and the
circumstantial evidence, and the innumerable
blatant inconsistencies in Z's stories.

He cited precedents for 2nd degree murder convictions,
in one case where the simple act of pointing a
gun and shooting someone was considered evidence
of a depraved state of mind. I felt he made the
case simply and precisely, and blew all
the defense bullshit out the window.

Originally I thought this was involuntary
manslaughter, ie that there had not been
any original sinister intent. I was skeptical that
he profiled because Trayvon was black.

As I learned more it seemed less involuntary
and more sinister, and I believed he could be
found guilty of aggravated manslaughter
(in this case specifically, murder of a child,
using a gun -- for which sentencing in FL is
nearly the same as for 2nd degree.)

But I didn't see how they could prove his
ill will, or depraved mind -- until I listened to
Richard Mantei's presentation on Friday. It was a
thing of beauty. He laid it all out, piece by
piece. There was nothing new -- it was how well
he presented the case. The case is already
proved, my opinion. He just needs to repeat
himself in his closing statement. The defense
has nothing.

If you're not watching the trial you're maybe
not aware that the defense is really horrible to
watch and listen to. I can't imagine the jury feels
much differently.

They are whiny, hostile, disrespectful, boring,
and they waste a HUGE amount of the judge and
jury's time with unproductive nitpicking. The judge
REALLY doesn't like wasting the jury's time, she
seems quite protective of them.

She doesn't seem to like the defense lawyers very
much, but I don't think it's political or pre-trial bias
as some are claiming.
It's just that they just act like assholes and are
frequently annoying and argumentative with her.

The clincher for me, like I said, was Richard Mantei's
presentation. It gave me great confidence in the
prosecution's competence.

My opinion now is that they have a very strong case,
pretty well backed up by forensics or lack thereof.
........

http://frederickleatherman.com/2013/07/06/will-the-defendant-testify-or-not-testify/

Someone on DU just posted that this blog is excellent,
and I agree so I'll refer you. They are liveblogging
the trial but also providing daily summary and
analysis.

He's also got some good info about what
"reasonable doubt" means.


The critical question, however, is whether the 6 women, 5 of whom are mothers, believe what the defendant told others. They are not required to believe anything he said. I doubt they will believe him, given his many contradictory statements, implausible claims, and the forensic evidence, particularly the DNA evidence, which proves that Trayvon Martin did not hit him 20-30 times in the face, grab his head and repeatedly slam it into a concrete sidewalk, or attempt to smother him by placing his hands over the defendantís nose and mouth.

I believe the prosecution has proved beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant provoked the encounter with Trayvon Martin by following him in a vehicle and then on foot after Trayvon attempted to elude him. He hunted him down and attempted to restrain him contrary to a request by the police dispatcher not to follow him and he never identified himself or explained why he was restraining him. Under these circumstances, Trayvon Martin was entitled to use reasonable force to defend himself, escalating to deadly force when the defendant pulled out his gun. Therefore, Trayvon Martin used lawful force to defend himself and the defendantís use of force was unlawful.

If he were my client, I would tell him that this is my assessment.

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 166 replies Author Time Post
XemaSab Jul 2013 OP
Voice for Peace Jul 2013 #1
dothemath Jul 2013 #20
jtuck004 Jul 2013 #64
cliffordu Jul 2013 #88
SleeplessinSoCal Jul 2013 #100
awoke_in_2003 Jul 2013 #101
Nanjing to Seoul Jul 2013 #108
demwing Jul 2013 #117
spanone Jul 2013 #120
Politicub Jul 2013 #125
graham4anything Jul 2013 #151
TrollBuster9090 Jul 2013 #45
MH1 Jul 2013 #46
JimDandy Jul 2013 #69
AtheistCrusader Jul 2013 #96
gejohnston Jul 2013 #98
Voice for Peace Jul 2013 #48
brush Jul 2013 #70
Voice for Peace Jul 2013 #50
TrollBuster9090 Jul 2013 #55
Voice for Peace Jul 2013 #57
grantcart Jul 2013 #124
LineLineLineLineLineLineLineReply it was the prosecution who convinced me.
Voice for Peace Jul 2013 #126
Ruby the Liberal Jul 2013 #127
Voice for Peace Jul 2013 #128
Ruby the Liberal Jul 2013 #129
grantcart Jul 2013 #130
WinstonSmith4740 Jul 2013 #58
Deep13 Jul 2013 #54
gejohnston Jul 2013 #99
TorchTheWitch Jul 2013 #103
Voice for Peace Jul 2013 #131
politicaljunkie41910 Jul 2013 #81
niyad Jul 2013 #83
Notafraidtoo Jul 2013 #102
Voice for Peace Jul 2013 #2
HiPointDem Jul 2013 #3
lumpy Jul 2013 #4
HipChick Jul 2013 #5
Warpy Jul 2013 #6
TrollBuster9090 Jul 2013 #49
ctsnowman Jul 2013 #27
Duer 157099 Jul 2013 #7
ecstatic Jul 2013 #10
Little Star Jul 2013 #13
Duer 157099 Jul 2013 #14
brush Jul 2013 #71
hedgehog Jul 2013 #24
XemaSab Jul 2013 #36
Hoyt Jul 2013 #8
woolldog Jul 2013 #22
MH1 Jul 2013 #47
woolldog Jul 2013 #67
SaveAmerica Jul 2013 #90
TorchTheWitch Jul 2013 #105
MH1 Jul 2013 #122
kudzu22 Jul 2013 #137
MH1 Jul 2013 #141
TrollBuster9090 Jul 2013 #51
WinstonSmith4740 Jul 2013 #62
woolldog Jul 2013 #66
csziggy Jul 2013 #97
yardwork Jul 2013 #68
protect our future Jul 2013 #119
TrollBuster9090 Jul 2013 #152
MH1 Jul 2013 #121
DallasNE Jul 2013 #87
obama2terms Jul 2013 #9
Tribalceltic Jul 2013 #11
Ruby the Liberal Jul 2013 #12
Mariana Jul 2013 #16
yardwork Jul 2013 #18
Starry Messenger Jul 2013 #30
Ruby the Liberal Jul 2013 #40
Starry Messenger Jul 2013 #104
AnnieK401 Jul 2013 #15
hedgehog Jul 2013 #25
yardwork Jul 2013 #17
Name removed Jul 2013 #32
hrmjustin Jul 2013 #33
Tom Ripley Jul 2013 #34
Name removed Jul 2013 #38
maddezmom Jul 2013 #35
HappyMe Jul 2013 #39
Ruby the Liberal Jul 2013 #41
HappyMe Jul 2013 #42
nadine_mn Jul 2013 #19
locdlib Jul 2013 #21
arcane1 Jul 2013 #23
TrollBuster9090 Jul 2013 #156
jbnow Jul 2013 #72
TorchTheWitch Jul 2013 #134
SaveOurDemocracy Jul 2013 #26
Voice for Peace Jul 2013 #59
ctsnowman Jul 2013 #28
Just Saying Jul 2013 #29
justiceischeap Jul 2013 #31
Powdered Toast Man Jul 2013 #37
NM_Birder Jul 2013 #43
Ruby the Liberal Jul 2013 #44
MADem Jul 2013 #52
TrollBuster9090 Jul 2013 #56
NM_Birder Jul 2013 #149
TrollBuster9090 Jul 2013 #153
NM_Birder Jul 2013 #158
TrollBuster9090 Jul 2013 #161
NM_Birder Jul 2013 #139
MADem Jul 2013 #140
NM_Birder Jul 2013 #142
MADem Jul 2013 #144
NM_Birder Jul 2013 #145
MADem Jul 2013 #146
NM_Birder Jul 2013 #148
TrollBuster9090 Jul 2013 #154
NM_Birder Jul 2013 #159
TrollBuster9090 Jul 2013 #160
TrollBuster9090 Jul 2013 #163
Voice for Peace Jul 2013 #63
yardwork Jul 2013 #116
TrollBuster9090 Jul 2013 #155
Voice for Peace Jul 2013 #157
NM_Birder Jul 2013 #164
TrollBuster9090 Jul 2013 #166
Hugabear Jul 2013 #86
TorchTheWitch Jul 2013 #109
TrollBuster9090 Jul 2013 #162
WinstonSmith4740 Jul 2013 #53
Ruby the Liberal Jul 2013 #60
JimDandy Jul 2013 #73
TorchTheWitch Jul 2013 #110
OldRedneck Jul 2013 #61
WinstonSmith4740 Jul 2013 #65
DallasNE Jul 2013 #106
Judi Lynn Jul 2013 #114
TorchTheWitch Jul 2013 #132
DallasNE Jul 2013 #135
TorchTheWitch Jul 2013 #133
DallasNE Jul 2013 #136
TorchTheWitch Jul 2013 #111
cntrygrl Jul 2013 #74
John2 Jul 2013 #75
cntrygrl Jul 2013 #165
renate Jul 2013 #82
cntrygrl Jul 2013 #138
Benton D Struckcheon Jul 2013 #76
arcane1 Jul 2013 #79
Benton D Struckcheon Jul 2013 #80
targetpractice Jul 2013 #91
DallasNE Jul 2013 #107
TorchTheWitch Jul 2013 #112
proReality Jul 2013 #77
tblue Jul 2013 #78
Voice for Peace Jul 2013 #95
TorchTheWitch Jul 2013 #113
Judi Lynn Jul 2013 #115
Liberal_Stalwart71 Jul 2013 #84
Pretzel_Warrior Jul 2013 #85
SaveAmerica Jul 2013 #89
targetpractice Jul 2013 #93
Rex Jul 2013 #92
rufus dog Jul 2013 #94
displacedtexan Jul 2013 #150
dusty trails Jul 2013 #118
libodem Jul 2013 #123
we can do it Jul 2013 #143
AtomicKitten Jul 2013 #147
Please login to view edit histories.