HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Main » General Discussion (Forum) » The second amendment is b...
Introducing Discussionist: A new forum by the creators of DU

Sun Apr 21, 2013, 01:15 AM

 

The second amendment is bullshit, and we all know it [View all]

I was glad to hear Bill Maher say it last week.

I am fully aware that the likelihood of an actual repeal of the second amendment is far fetched, to say the least. That is not the topic of this post. I am not talking about the likelihood, popularity of, or support for the full repeal of the second amendment. I am talking about the validity of the second amendment itself.

Comparisons of the second amendment with the first, or with any of the others, or with prohibition (an amendment that was ironically, REPEALED!), are invalid. If you counter my argument that the second amendment is bullshit by citing the others, you are committing the slippery slope logical fallacy. You're changing the subject.

The reasons that the founding fathers included the second amendment in the bill of rights is also a dodge. Those reasons, whether they were valid or not at the time, have no bearing on the validity of the second amendment today. Laws change over time, all the time, including amendments to the Constitution (see: Prohibition).

The fact of the matter is, if America wants to actually solve the problem of gun violence, the only way to do it is a full repeal of this law. No other civilized nation on Earth has anything remotely resembling a "right" to "bear arms". I put the word "right" in quotes because to say that owning a firearm is some sort of inalienable human right is complete and utter bullshit. We all know it, so let's just say it. I understand why Obama and everyone else have to pretend like they want to solve this problem "while still respecting second amendment rights", but again, that's not the subject of this post.

The fact of the matter is, America has more gun related deaths, both homicides, suicides, accidents, and the like, than any other first world nation on the planet. When gun nuts cite the dropping numbers of gun deaths over the years, or the drop in crime in general over the years, they conveniently ignore the fact that despite the trend other countries have gun crime rates orders of magnitude below America. There is 1 per capita gun crime in Canada for every seven in America. Seven. That's not some minor blip. That's 700%. How many people here would like a stock they might own to increase 700%?

The fact of the matter is the UK, Canada, Japan, France, and the like all play the same video games, all watch the same TV shows and violent movies, all have violent histories. What these other countries DO NOT have is an obsolete, ill advised, bullshit law etched into their Constitutions that give people a "right" to own a gun. These other countries have been able to pass laws restricting gun ownership, regulating it, setting up registries and background checks and the like, because they don't have some stupid amendment in their Constitutions making it damn near impossible for them to do so.

The fact of the matter is these other countries have not, I repeat, have not BANNED ALL GUNS. If you live in Canada, you can buy a gun. If you live in the UK, you can buy a gun. You have to jump through a lot of hoops, you are restricted to only certain types of guns, etcetera. The so called "responsible gun owners" in these other countries actually ARE responsible gun owners, because the system is set up to make sure that they are. They have to get background checks, and licenses, and have to pass tests, be put into a national registry, etcetera. They may not have a "right" etched into their constitutions, but they still own guns. Can you imagine if all you had to do to drive a car was buy one? (And to cite the high level of deaths by auto accident is also a change of subject, as auto deaths would undoubtedly be FAR HIGHER if not for the restrictions on licensing and registering).

The fact of the matter is that criminals who are hell bent on getting guns do not generally succeed at getting guns in these other countries. While a few may, the vast majority of criminals have a hell of a difficult time getting their hands on a gun when guns are regulated to the extent that they are in these other countries. They usually opt for knives or bats, or other things that are objectively (NOT subjectively, OBJECTIVELY) far less lethal than guns. And the guns that they usually DO get their hands on are still far less lethal than the bushmaster .223 or other similarly designed military style weapons that should only see a battlefield. And just as a little side note here, before I get too off topic, I want to say that guns are not TOOLS like hammers or saws or knives or pickaxes. While these TOOLS may be used for lethal purposes, guns are WEAPONS. Label them as such.

The fact of the matter is that this so called "freedom" and "right" to own a gun is what's holding America back from solving this problem that has already been solved in every other civilized nation on Earth. Gun nuts need to stop bullshitting themselves and bullshitting everyone else. You don't have your guns because it's your right to have them. You have them because you LIKE them. You get off on shooting them. It's a fetish. It's a vice. You grew up with it, passed down through the generations, and you think it's normal. And you know what? That's OK for you. But you're vice is harming society.

The fact of the matter is that EVERY SINGLE GUN shot by a criminal was once purchased by one of you. They got their hands on it somehow because you sold it, or you lost it, or it got stolen from you. You were irresponsible somewhere along the line, and the government had no power to make sure that your gun was traced somehow. They had no power to do it because they can't get past this bullshit thing called the second amendment. They can't pass a law to make sure that you truly are the responsible gun owner you say you are. And guess what? You're most likely not. You're most likely going to shoot a family member with it. You're most likely going to kill yourself, either intentionally or accidentally, with it. These are statistical facts, not opinions. Everybody thinks it will never happen to them until it actually does. Stats is stats, math is math, reality is reality.

The fact of the matter is that other civilized countries have social safety nets like universal health care, and that does help. America doesn't do enough in terms of education, mental health, and the like. But creating a true social safety net in America, while not doing anything about the gun laws, will only serve to reduce violence overall, but not GUN VIOLENCE in particular. The people who fall through the social safety net will still have easy access to guns, unlike the people in other countries who opt to use knives. Again, knives and other things that can do harm to others are FAR LESS LIKELY to be as lethal as guns. On the very same calendar day of the Sandy Hook shooting - THE SAME DAMN DAY, a man in China attacked school children with a knife. Not one of those children died.

The second amendment. That's the problem. Let's stop beating around the bush. Let's stop kidding ourselves. Enough bullshit. Until America repeals the second amendment, the gun problem will continue to exist. The gun problem is real. It is not imaginary. The numbers are the numbers. When 7 people are killed by a gun in America for every 1 person in Canada, the gun nuts can cite every single statistic in their book of tricks that they want to. Falling crime rates, lower crime rates in right to carry areas, whatever the hell they want to cite. They cannot refute the first fact. What's the point of saying gun crime rates are falling, or that gun crime rates are lower in right to carry areas when you purposely ignore the fact that the gun crime rates are still astronomically higher than in other countries that solved this problem? The point is to obfuscate. To lie. To change the subject. To keep everyone distracted from the fact that the gun problem is real and that it's not going away any time soon.

At least not until the second amendment is repealed. Likely to happen? Of course not. But it is what must happen.

121 replies, 14665 views

Reply to this thread

Back to top Alert abuse

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 121 replies Author Time Post
Reply The second amendment is bullshit, and we all know it [View all]
Uzair Apr 2013 OP
defacto7 Apr 2013 #1
rrneck Apr 2013 #2
rightsideout Apr 2013 #3
SammyWinstonJack Apr 2013 #40
Loudly Apr 2013 #4
friendly_iconoclast Apr 2013 #17
ProgressiveProfessor Apr 2013 #36
Loudly Apr 2013 #87
ProgressiveProfessor Apr 2013 #88
Loudly Apr 2013 #90
rsmith6621 Apr 2013 #5
Zoeisright Apr 2013 #9
rsmith6621 Apr 2013 #51
sarisataka Apr 2013 #6
Uzair Apr 2013 #52
pintobean Apr 2013 #58
sarisataka Apr 2013 #65
Skittles Apr 2013 #89
Electric Monk Apr 2013 #96
Skittles Apr 2013 #98
Occulus Apr 2013 #119
pintobean Apr 2013 #121
sylvi Apr 2013 #100
Skittles Apr 2013 #102
sylvi Apr 2013 #103
Skittles Apr 2013 #104
sylvi Apr 2013 #105
sylvi Apr 2013 #106
Walk away Apr 2013 #86
Warpy Apr 2013 #7
SunSeeker Apr 2013 #8
ErikJ Apr 2013 #10
friendly_iconoclast Apr 2013 #20
Eleanors38 Apr 2013 #56
Mr.Pain Apr 2013 #11
newmember Apr 2013 #12
Mr.Pain Apr 2013 #16
newmember Apr 2013 #23
ErikJ Apr 2013 #15
MillennialDem Apr 2013 #13
Recursion Apr 2013 #31
Phillip McCleod Apr 2013 #91
AtheistCrusader Apr 2013 #14
friendly_iconoclast Apr 2013 #19
Pelican Apr 2013 #50
LittleBlue Apr 2013 #18
MillennialDem Apr 2013 #22
Recursion Apr 2013 #32
MillennialDem Apr 2013 #46
Recursion Apr 2013 #47
MillennialDem Apr 2013 #48
Spitfire of ATJ Apr 2013 #21
hack89 Apr 2013 #108
Spitfire of ATJ Apr 2013 #109
hack89 Apr 2013 #110
Spitfire of ATJ Apr 2013 #113
hack89 Apr 2013 #114
moondust Apr 2013 #24
newmember Apr 2013 #25
Apophis Apr 2013 #26
Mr.Pain Apr 2013 #27
smirkymonkey Apr 2013 #28
DallasNE Apr 2013 #29
GoCubsGo Apr 2013 #38
Recursion Apr 2013 #30
jmowreader Apr 2013 #71
Shrek Apr 2013 #33
OneGrassRoot Apr 2013 #34
darkangel218 Apr 2013 #35
99Forever Apr 2013 #37
newmember Apr 2013 #42
DanTex Apr 2013 #39
Zax2me Apr 2013 #44
DanTex Apr 2013 #45
LAGC Apr 2013 #73
MOTRDemocrat Apr 2013 #41
Zax2me Apr 2013 #43
Blecht Apr 2013 #49
Dreamer Tatum Apr 2013 #53
Eleanors38 Apr 2013 #54
treestar Apr 2013 #55
Hugabear Apr 2013 #57
Uzair Apr 2013 #59
Daniel537 Apr 2013 #60
Uzair Apr 2013 #62
cherokeeprogressive Apr 2013 #68
DanTex Apr 2013 #78
DanTex Apr 2013 #79
pintobean Apr 2013 #61
Uzair Apr 2013 #63
Hugabear Apr 2013 #64
pintobean Apr 2013 #66
DanTex Apr 2013 #77
pintobean Apr 2013 #80
DanTex Apr 2013 #82
laundry_queen Apr 2013 #107
Phillip McCleod Apr 2013 #92
pintobean Apr 2013 #93
Ter Apr 2013 #94
The Straight Story Apr 2013 #67
Electric Monk Apr 2013 #75
The Straight Story Apr 2013 #83
Electric Monk Apr 2013 #84
truebluegreen Apr 2013 #69
AlinPA Apr 2013 #70
Pelican Apr 2013 #111
galileoreloaded Apr 2013 #72
badtoworse Apr 2013 #95
Locrian Apr 2013 #74
friendly_iconoclast Apr 2013 #76
Uzair Apr 2013 #81
friendly_iconoclast Apr 2013 #115
aikoaiko Apr 2013 #85
badtoworse Apr 2013 #97
sylvi Apr 2013 #99
bvar22 Apr 2013 #101
kenny blankenship Apr 2013 #112
friendly_iconoclast Apr 2013 #116
Bake Apr 2013 #117
Uzair Apr 2013 #118
Bake Apr 2013 #120