HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Main » General Discussion (Forum) » Were Early Christians Rea...

Wed Feb 27, 2013, 07:26 AM

Were Early Christians Really Persecuted? Historian Reveals the Surprising Truth. [View all]

This discussion thread was locked as off-topic by MineralMan (a host of the General Discussion forum).

http://www.alternet.org/belief/were-early-christians-really-persecuted-historian-reveals-surprising-truth



In the immediate aftermath of the Columbine High School massacre, a modern myth was born. A story went around that one of the two killers asked one of the victims, Cassie Bernall, if she believed in God. Bernall reportedly said “Yes” just before he shot her. Bernall’s mother wrote a memoir, titled “She Said Yes: The Unlikely Martyrdom of Cassie Bernall,” a tribute to her daughter’s courageous Christian faith. Then, just as the book was being published, a student who was hiding near Bernall told journalist Dave Cullen that the exchange never happened.

Although Candida Moss’ new book, “The Myth of Persecution: How Early Christians Invented a Story of Martyrdom,” is about the three centuries following the death of Jesus, she makes a point of citing this modern-day parallel. What Bernall truly said and did in the moments before her death absolutely matters, Moss asserts, if we are going to hold her up as a “martyr.” Yet misconceptions and misrepresentations can creep in so soon. The public can get the story wrong even in this highly mediated and thoroughly reported age — and do so despite the presence among us of living eyewitnesses. So what, then, to make of the third-hand, heavily revised, agenda-laden and anachronistic accounts of Christianity’s originalmartyrs?

Moss, professor of New Testament and early Christianity at the University of Notre Dame, challenges some of the most hallowed legends of the religion when she questions what she calls “the Sunday school narrative of a church of martyrs, of Christians huddled in catacombs out of fear, meeting in secret to avoid arrest and mercilessly thrown to lions merely for their religious beliefs.” None of that, she maintains, is true. In the 300 years between the death of Jesus and the conversion of the Emperor Constantine, there were maybe 10 or 12 scattered years during which Christians were singled out for supression by Rome’s imperial authorities, and even then the enforcement of such initiatives was haphazard — lackadaisical in many regions, although harsh in others. “Christians were never,” Moss writes, “the victims of sustained, targeted persecution.”

Much of the middle section of “The Myth of Persecution” is taken up with a close reading of the six “so-called authentic accounts” of the church’s first martyrs. They include Polycarp, a bishop in Smyrna during the second century who was burned at the stake, and Saint Perpetua, a well-born young mother executed in the arena at Carthage with her slave, Felicity, at the beginning of the third century. Moss carefully points out the inconsistencies between these tales and what we know about Roman society, the digs at heresies that didn’t even exist when the martyrs were killed and the references to martyrdom traditions that had yet to be established. There’s surely some kernel of truth to these stories, she explains, as well as to the first substantive history of the church written in 311 by a Palestinian named Eusebius. It’s just that it’s impossible to sort the truth from the colorful inventions, the ax-grinding and the attempts to reinforce the orthodoxies of a later age.

92 replies, 5861 views

Cannot reply in locked threads

Back to top Alert abuse

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 92 replies Author Time Post
Reply Were Early Christians Really Persecuted? Historian Reveals the Surprising Truth. [View all]
xchrom Feb 2013 OP
reformist2 Feb 2013 #1
MNBrewer Feb 2013 #4
Recursion Feb 2013 #14
MNBrewer Feb 2013 #23
sunwyn Feb 2013 #83
OceanEcosystem Feb 2013 #90
A HERETIC I AM Feb 2013 #34
alcibiades_mystery Feb 2013 #43
A HERETIC I AM Feb 2013 #46
Major Nikon Feb 2013 #48
Recursion Feb 2013 #49
Major Nikon Feb 2013 #51
davidthegnome Feb 2013 #63
joeybee12 Feb 2013 #69
midwest irish Feb 2013 #76
joeybee12 Feb 2013 #77
midwest irish Feb 2013 #78
davidthegnome Feb 2013 #79
LibertyLover Feb 2013 #87
ColesCountyDem Feb 2013 #47
riqster Feb 2013 #2
OldDem2012 Feb 2013 #3
MNBrewer Feb 2013 #5
zeemike Feb 2013 #26
A HERETIC I AM Feb 2013 #36
zeemike Feb 2013 #60
Swede Atlanta Feb 2013 #6
MNBrewer Feb 2013 #24
Ikonoklast Feb 2013 #84
intaglio Feb 2013 #7
tavalon Feb 2013 #11
intaglio Feb 2013 #81
el_bryanto Feb 2013 #8
skygazer Feb 2013 #61
randr Feb 2013 #9
SemperEadem Feb 2013 #12
Zax2me Feb 2013 #13
randr Feb 2013 #15
midwest irish Feb 2013 #80
reformist2 Feb 2013 #17
Zax2me Feb 2013 #10
Fumesucker Feb 2013 #16
SkyDaddy7 Feb 2013 #21
OceanEcosystem Feb 2013 #37
Arugula Latte Feb 2013 #62
Zax2me Feb 2013 #18
deutsey Feb 2013 #22
ET Awful Feb 2013 #42
OceanEcosystem Feb 2013 #19
OceanEcosystem Feb 2013 #20
Fumesucker Feb 2013 #53
MotherPetrie Feb 2013 #25
mountain grammy Feb 2013 #27
OceanEcosystem Feb 2013 #29
mountain grammy Feb 2013 #30
OceanEcosystem Feb 2013 #33
mountain grammy Feb 2013 #39
OceanEcosystem Feb 2013 #44
Fumesucker Feb 2013 #88
OceanEcosystem Feb 2013 #89
Marr Feb 2013 #72
dmallind Feb 2013 #41
OceanEcosystem Feb 2013 #45
FreeState Feb 2013 #52
OceanEcosystem Feb 2013 #54
dmallind Feb 2013 #57
Arugula Latte Feb 2013 #68
Arugula Latte Feb 2013 #67
Bucky Feb 2013 #28
Demeter Feb 2013 #31
dmallind Feb 2013 #32
trotsky Feb 2013 #35
blackspade Feb 2013 #38
alcibiades_mystery Feb 2013 #40
mountain grammy Feb 2013 #50
OceanEcosystem Feb 2013 #56
mountain grammy Feb 2013 #65
OceanEcosystem Feb 2013 #71
mountain grammy Feb 2013 #85
OceanEcosystem Feb 2013 #86
mountain grammy Feb 2013 #91
6000eliot Feb 2013 #55
thetruthhurtsforsome Feb 2013 #58
knitter4democracy Feb 2013 #59
onehandle Feb 2013 #64
Shadowflash Feb 2013 #66
Marr Feb 2013 #70
HarveyDarkey Feb 2013 #73
Taverner Feb 2013 #74
Igel Feb 2013 #75
KittyWampus Feb 2013 #82
MineralMan Feb 2013 #92