HomeLatest ThreadsGreatest ThreadsForums & GroupsMy SubscriptionsMy Posts
DU Home » Latest Threads » Forums & Groups » Main » General Discussion (Forum) » Only a real coward would ... » Reply #85

Reply #85


Response to Fumesucker (Reply #80)

Fri Jan 4, 2013, 12:40 PM

85. Agree and the Heller opinion said:

 

Before addressing the verbs “keep” and “bear,” we interpret their object: “Arms.” The 18th-century meaning is no different from the meaning today. The 1773 edition of Samuel Johnson’s dictionary defined “arms” as “weapons of offence, or armour of defence.” 1 Dictionary of the English Language 107 (4th ed.) (hereinafter Johnson). Timothy Cunningham’s important 1771 legal dictionary defined “arms” as “any thing that a man wears for his defence, or takes into his hands, or useth in wrath to cast at or strike another.” 1 A New and Complete Law Dictionary (1771); see also N. Webster, American Dictionary of the English Language (1828) (reprinted 1989) (hereinafter Webster) (similar).

The term was applied, then as now, to weapons that were not specifically designed for military use and were not employed in a military capacity. For instance, Cunningham’s legal dictionary gave as an example of usage: “Servants and labourers shall use bows and arrows on Sundays, &c. and not bear other arms.” See also, e.g., An Act for the trial of Negroes, 1797 Del. Laws ch. XLIII, §6, p. 104, in 1 First Laws of the State of Delaware 102, 104 (J. Cushing ed. 1981 (pt. 1)); see generally State v. Duke, 42Tex. 455, 458 (1874) (citing decisions of state courts construing “arms”). Although one founding-era thesaurus limited “arms” (as opposed to “weapons”) to “instruments of offence generally made use of in war,” even that source stated that all firearms constituted “arms.” 1 J. Trusler, The Distinction Between Words Esteemed Synonymous in the English Language37 (1794) (emphasis added).

Some have made the argument, bordering on the frivolous, that only those arms in existence in the 18th century are protected by the Second Amendment . We do not interpret constitutional rights that way. Just as the First Amendment protects modern forms of communications, e.g., Reno v. American Civil Liberties Union, 521 U. S. 844, 849 (1997) , and the Fourth Amendment applies to modern forms of search, e.g., Kyllo v. United States, 533 U. S. 27, 35–36 (2001) , the Second Amendment extends, prima facie,to all instruments that constitute bearable arms, even those that were not in existence at the time of the founding.

Reply to this post

Back to OP Alert abuse Link to post in-thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Arrow 87 replies Author Time Post
kelliekat44 Jan 2013 OP
jody Jan 2013 #1
spanone Jan 2013 #2
jody Jan 2013 #4
neverforget Jan 2013 #12
ProgressiveProfessor Jan 2013 #6
white_wolf Jan 2013 #9
Fumesucker Jan 2013 #3
jody Jan 2013 #5
Fumesucker Jan 2013 #11
Berserker Jan 2013 #10
Fumesucker Jan 2013 #14
hack89 Jan 2013 #48
Fumesucker Jan 2013 #49
hack89 Jan 2013 #52
Fumesucker Jan 2013 #57
hack89 Jan 2013 #58
Fumesucker Jan 2013 #59
hack89 Jan 2013 #60
Fumesucker Jan 2013 #61
hack89 Jan 2013 #62
Fumesucker Jan 2013 #63
hack89 Jan 2013 #65
Fumesucker Jan 2013 #66
hack89 Jan 2013 #67
Fumesucker Jan 2013 #68
hack89 Jan 2013 #69
Fumesucker Jan 2013 #70
hack89 Jan 2013 #71
Fumesucker Jan 2013 #72
hack89 Jan 2013 #73
Fumesucker Jan 2013 #74
hack89 Jan 2013 #75
Fumesucker Jan 2013 #80
hack89 Jan 2013 #81
LineLineLineLineLineLineLineLineLineLineNew Reply Agree and the Heller opinion said:
jody Jan 2013 #85
duhneece Jan 2013 #78
Honeycombe8 Jan 2013 #19
Fumesucker Jan 2013 #22
Honeycombe8 Jan 2013 #43
Fumesucker Jan 2013 #44
madokie Jan 2013 #47
Puzzledtraveller Jan 2013 #50
Fumesucker Jan 2013 #51
nadinbrzezinski Jan 2013 #7
white_wolf Jan 2013 #8
jody Jan 2013 #13
Fumesucker Jan 2013 #16
jody Jan 2013 #23
Fumesucker Jan 2013 #24
jody Jan 2013 #26
Fumesucker Jan 2013 #31
jody Jan 2013 #34
Fumesucker Jan 2013 #40
jody Jan 2013 #84
madinmaryland Jan 2013 #15
Occulus Jan 2013 #17
MightyMopar Jan 2013 #53
rrneck Jan 2013 #64
jmg257 Jan 2013 #18
-..__... Jan 2013 #20
Fumesucker Jan 2013 #25
-..__... Jan 2013 #27
dionysus Jan 2013 #29
-..__... Jan 2013 #33
JTFrog Jan 2013 #86
dionysus Jan 2013 #87
Fumesucker Jan 2013 #32
-..__... Jan 2013 #35
Fumesucker Jan 2013 #36
-..__... Jan 2013 #37
Fumesucker Jan 2013 #39
-..__... Jan 2013 #41
Auntie Bush Jan 2013 #21
MrSlayer Jan 2013 #28
cliffordu Jan 2013 #30
Marinedem Jan 2013 #38
former-republican Jan 2013 #42
flvegan Jan 2013 #45
Egalitarian Thug Jan 2013 #46
Atman Jan 2013 #54
Pholus Jan 2013 #55
duhneece Jan 2013 #83
GreenStormCloud Jan 2013 #56
samsingh Jan 2013 #76
and-justice-for-all Jan 2013 #77
X_Digger Jan 2013 #79
ZombieHorde Jan 2013 #82
Please login to view edit histories.