Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

dmallind

(10,437 posts)
102. How will the test takers know about the 50 rapes that are not in this sample?
Tue Nov 27, 2012, 03:30 PM
Nov 2012

You keep switching complaints between obscurity and obscenity. They can't be true at the same time. If they are unfamiliar enough with the text to deem it obscure they won't know about the rapes. If they know the book well enough to know about the rapes (which are far less graphic than on broadcast TV) then they will hardly find it all that obscure.

Which is the real problem? that a 2000 year old text includes some bowdlerized sexual violence (which is apparently worse to you than the graphic torture and slaughter of both sexes in The Hunger Games) or that kids don't understand imagery any more and get frustrated at words less faddish than "l8er"?

Here's an example of those terrible rape scenes by the way folks...

"The sun was high, just path the zenith, when she entered a grove that had been untouched through the years. Here she took her quiver from her shoulder, unstrung her curved bow, and lay down on the grass, her head resting on her painted quiver. Jupiter, seeing her there weary and unprotected, said ‘Here, surely, my wife will not see my cunning, or if she does find out it is, oh it is, worth a quarrel! Quickly he took on the face and dress of Diana, and said ‘Oh, girl who follows me, where in my domains have you been hunting?’

The virgin girl got up from the turf replying ‘Greetings, goddess greater than Jupiter: I say it even though he himself hears it.’ He did hear, and laughed, happy to be judged greater than himself, and gave her kisses unrestrainedly, and not those that virgins give. When she started to say which woods she had hunted he embraced and prevented her and not without committing a crime. Face to face with him, as far as a woman could, (I wish you had seen her Juno: you would have been kinder to her) she fought him, but how could a girl win, and who is more powerful than Jove? Victorious, Jupiter made for the furthest reaches of the sky: while to Callisto the grove was odious and the wood seemed knowing. As she retraced her steps she almost forgot her quiver and its arrows, and the bow she had left hanging."


Yep - that horror is apparently a valid reason not to include a poet who has endured for over twenty centuries on a literatire exam.....

What's wrong with Ovid? Perfectly reasonable component of a solid education in the humanities dmallind Nov 2012 #1
Perfectly reasonable. enlightenment Nov 2012 #5
99% of teens would find it boring and/or painful to read. pnwmom Nov 2012 #9
Yes, because having to think about one passage will destroy them for life. Posteritatis Nov 2012 #15
No, it won't. But Ovid is overrated, as a teaching device anyway. pnwmom Nov 2012 #20
The same could be said of Shakespeare intaglio Nov 2012 #94
How many plays of Shakespeare include 50 rapes? pnwmom Nov 2012 #95
Neither does "Merchant" by those lights intaglio Nov 2012 #109
that just makes me sad. It's a beautiful play cali Nov 2012 #115
Quite a few adults would, too Fla_Democrat Nov 2012 #18
Dare I say "most"? HiPointDem Nov 2012 #32
If that's their reaction, reading is already ruined. aquart Nov 2012 #62
Student: "Why are we reading Ovid's handbook on rape?" pnwmom Nov 2012 #65
not everyone has the same tastes in literature... BlueMan Votes Nov 2012 #79
since common core mandates that only 30% of texts taught in HS english can be literature, HiPointDem Nov 2012 #140
I think 99% is perhaps a bit overbaked. enlightenment Nov 2012 #82
May be so. But I still don't understand why high school students pnwmom Nov 2012 #84
Because it's poetry? Because it's old? Retrograde Nov 2012 #103
There are countless old poems out there. They don't need to assign The Metamorphoses pnwmom Nov 2012 #108
Can they do Titus Andronicus? (n/t) Retrograde Nov 2012 #114
What do you think? Is it one of the best? pnwmom Nov 2012 #116
Oh please. This is embarrassing. Might as well dispense with Classics entirely under your regime. anneboleyn Nov 2012 #137
What a horrible, shallow rationale for dumbing down curricula. anneboleyn Nov 2012 #136
shallow is your uniformed post. HiPointDem Nov 2012 #142
Exactly. Ovid, Shakespeare, etc. WTH is the problem? It is "poetry" and therefore too "hard?" anneboleyn Nov 2012 #135
Good lord! Are_grits_groceries Nov 2012 #2
What? I loved reading Ovid in high school. MineralMan Nov 2012 #4
they don't read it. ovid isn't on the 10th-grade reading list. they just get HiPointDem Nov 2012 #48
It was on my 10th grade reading list. MineralMan Nov 2012 #60
it's not on the common core reading list, which most of the states will soon HiPointDem Nov 2012 #74
Oh I can see a number of things this tests that are appropriate... HereSince1628 Nov 2012 #19
Should students be expected to study a text pnwmom Nov 2012 #89
IMO, although that clearly activates your sensibilities, it's a red herring HereSince1628 Nov 2012 #96
Teaching to the test means that many students are likely to be taught pnwmom Nov 2012 #99
I don't think this is a teaching to the test issue...because the nature of the assessement HereSince1628 Nov 2012 #111
can you also imagine what students would make of 'modest proposal' if they met it cold HiPointDem Nov 2012 #129
Pretending society has the same hundreds/thousands of years ago AlexSatan Nov 2012 #97
With all the beautiful and/or difficult reading passages that could be assigned from other works, pnwmom Nov 2012 #100
Now that, AlexSatan Nov 2012 #113
Is it a required test? For all 10th graders? I don't recall having to take a test in 10th grade. Honeycombe8 Nov 2012 #119
Common Core Tests. Every year. HiPointDem Nov 2012 #127
That article says the tests are to go into effect in 2014-2015? Honeycombe8 Nov 2012 #130
no, i meant they will be given every year, to all students. at least once, possibly twice, HiPointDem Nov 2012 #133
This whole testing mania is about profit -- for the testing companies pnwmom Nov 2012 #138
+1 HiPointDem Nov 2012 #139
I thoroughly enjoyed reading that.... mike_c Nov 2012 #3
I knew I'd get the "I love Ovid, especially in 100-year-old translation" from the HiPointDem Nov 2012 #6
Appreciate it might be asking to much... Riftaxe Nov 2012 #41
Do you know a lot of typical 10th graders? And by that I mean, pnwmom Nov 2012 #141
Enjoyed the reading too. PufPuf23 Nov 2012 #45
I don't think all education should be about the "global economy" Union Scribe Nov 2012 #76
but according to the folks pushing this, it's all about educating kids for the global economy. HiPointDem Nov 2012 #93
Your answer choices are A), B), C) or TL/DR) Bucky Nov 2012 #7
This isn't the way to encourage a generation of readers. pnwmom Nov 2012 #8
That's one of the more inane objections I've heard to, well, anything here. (nt) Posteritatis Nov 2012 #14
How many English classes have you taught or observed? n/t pnwmom Nov 2012 #16
What bearing does that have on deciding poetry's for the 1%? (nt) Posteritatis Nov 2012 #17
If you knew high school students you would know there would only be a few pnwmom Nov 2012 #21
Nope, not even them. knitter4democracy Nov 2012 #24
I meant 1% in ability and interest, not in financial background. pnwmom Nov 2012 #91
It's a passage I'd expect on the AP anyway. knitter4democracy Nov 2012 #117
Holy phuking wow! You could not be more wrong. Please describe your personal patrice Nov 2012 #29
Why should I? Anyone who works with teens knows that most of them pnwmom Nov 2012 #38
What should they read in school then? Union Scribe Nov 2012 #78
Frankenstein is pretty good. roody Nov 2012 #80
How about Shakespeare? (But not The Taming of the Shrew) pnwmom Nov 2012 #92
I had 2 alternative high school students almost come to blows over that book. knitter4democracy Nov 2012 #118
Is that the purpose of the test? surrealAmerican Nov 2012 #30
If passages like this are known to be on a test, they WILL be central to the curriculum. pnwmom Nov 2012 #35
So people who enjoy reading, MineralMan Nov 2012 #61
You can love to read, as I did, and dislike Ovid pnwmom Nov 2012 #66
But I bet reading him helped you improve your skills at critique. wickerwoman Nov 2012 #81
There were countless other difficult texts I could have read instead in order pnwmom Nov 2012 #83
What an appalling comment. Nightmarish. aquart Nov 2012 #63
+1 with many zeros on the end. nt Union Scribe Nov 2012 #77
The 1% don't read; they have people to do that for them. wickerwoman Nov 2012 #90
It's OK so long as they explain that humans can't actually fly this way. FarCenter Nov 2012 #10
Why should children not learn classical literature? Skidmore Nov 2012 #11
For 4 decades I tried to teach undergrads biology... HereSince1628 Nov 2012 #12
four decades...? mike_c Nov 2012 #55
Yes, how dare those poor snowflakes have to read something complex for a change. Posteritatis Nov 2012 #13
Ovid's Metamorphoses contains over 50 references to rapes. pnwmom Nov 2012 #23
Literatures reflect their times Skidmore Nov 2012 #36
Yet you upthread recommended books that contain many more *deaths* than that dmallind Nov 2012 #101
Ovid is simply montanto Nov 2012 #22
And there's the crux of the matter: what approach? knitter4democracy Nov 2012 #25
If they want kids to read Ovid, it should be "The Art of Love". Cleita Nov 2012 #26
"... the kind of reading students will have to ENDURE ..." Do you recognize your own bias? nt patrice Nov 2012 #27
If kids aren't used to reading archaic language they're going to have a hard time with that Fumesucker Nov 2012 #28
Well, jeez. isn't that the very type of circumstance for which we should to teach research skills Skidmore Nov 2012 #39
This is a test, not a research project.. Fumesucker Nov 2012 #42
I know what "rustic," "pipe," "prom," and "straws" all mean. pnwmom Nov 2012 #44
Put them together and what've you got? Fumesucker Nov 2012 #46
Pretty much. n/t pnwmom Nov 2012 #47
ovid isn't on the 10th grade reading list. this is just a passage that they HiPointDem Nov 2012 #50
ovid isn't in common core's 10th grade reading, i.e. it won't be taught. they HiPointDem Nov 2012 #75
What's to research? Retrograde Nov 2012 #106
my post was to counter the idea that students will actually be studying ovid. but the HiPointDem Nov 2012 #107
Student: "Why are we reading Ovid's handbook on rape?" pnwmom Nov 2012 #31
Challenge is the essence of cognitive development. It should be appropriate, but inappropriate patrice Nov 2012 #33
The Metamorphoses isn't just challenging. It's sexist and misogynistic and includes pnwmom Nov 2012 #34
That's okay with me as long as it isn't about avoiding reading challenges. Discussion is patrice Nov 2012 #37
But in a test situation there's no discussion involved. pnwmom Nov 2012 #40
Your point about the testing environment is taken. I was thinking about curriculum in general... patrice Nov 2012 #43
ovid isn't part of the 10th-grade curriculum. it's just a test question. HiPointDem Nov 2012 #51
How will the test takers know about the 50 rapes that are not in this sample? dmallind Nov 2012 #102
The fact that it is couched in poetic language doesn't make it less of a rape. "She fought him." pnwmom Nov 2012 #110
So...nongraphic rape descriptions are, to you, worse than graphic torture and killing descriptions? dmallind Nov 2012 #112
What an insipid critique by your source. I would have been tested on Ovid in the original Latin, msanthrope Nov 2012 #49
Ugh, not only is it a wretched story to begin with Warpy Nov 2012 #52
I don't see anything wrong with this - downandoutnow Nov 2012 #53
Welcome to DU! hrmjustin Nov 2012 #64
It's how testing is done in many other countries... WilmywoodNCparalegal Nov 2012 #54
ovid is not on the common core 10th grade reading list. it's just a test HiPointDem Nov 2012 #56
here's a different perspective.... mike_c Nov 2012 #57
"haven't had any serious prior exposure to the passage in the test." HiPointDem Nov 2012 #58
Uh huh and the current gripe is that schools don't teach job skills or that schools MichiganVote Nov 2012 #59
We could just give them this machine assembly manual: bhikkhu Nov 2012 #86
Mirabile dictu! A flamewar on Ovid. rug Nov 2012 #67
<snort> Fumesucker Nov 2012 #68
Ave, amice rug Nov 2012 #69
I tip my hat to you....I think Virgil declined. nt msanthrope Nov 2012 #104
Long before Schoolhouse Rock, there was this. rug Nov 2012 #132
So you are upset about children learning to read. Cool. cthulu2016 Nov 2012 #70
Your comments are generally much smarter than that Fumesucker Nov 2012 #72
Basically. joshcryer Nov 2012 #105
30 years, high school English, Tech-Prep 11, Honors 10, C-P 12. THIS EXCERPT SUCKS. WinkyDink Nov 2012 #71
Wait until they get to his love manual! Odin2005 Nov 2012 #73
On any assessment there will be questions only the top % of students will master aikoaiko Nov 2012 #85
I'm a high school English teacher Nevernose Nov 2012 #87
What's wrong with Homer? Isn't that more popular with kids? nt Honeycombe8 Nov 2012 #120
i like the newer translation in the link for teaching NuttyFluffers Nov 2012 #88
I think it is great. We underestimate the kids and what are we saying if something I learned in high Pisces Nov 2012 #98
Good. I want students to be challenged RZM Nov 2012 #121
so it's standardized tests that challenge students? i thought it was curriculum HiPointDem Nov 2012 #122
Ideally they are challenged on a regular basis RZM Nov 2012 #124
There is a reason. Classical greek/romance literature written in archaic english isn't part HiPointDem Nov 2012 #125
It's not any worse then the stuff I had to read in 9th or 10th grade. Jennicut Nov 2012 #123
excellent Deep13 Nov 2012 #126
yea, testing them on something they didn't study will help a lot. and more testing will HiPointDem Nov 2012 #128
I meant excellent that Sophmores were being exposed to Ovid. Deep13 Nov 2012 #131
the only place they're being exposed is on the test itself. not a good space for a 1st HiPointDem Nov 2012 #134
That's bad. Deep13 Nov 2012 #143
Latest Discussions»General Discussion»Here's what your 10th-gra...»Reply #102