Concerning WilliamPitt's post....
http://www.democraticunderground.com/10022509955
That was an incredible thread. There was so much information, so much work and effort by all sides to hash out their demons, I really don't see how that could possibly be locked. I understand the letter of the law reasoning and the "feelings/opinions" of the hosts but it is a shame to snuff out anger and defence in what I see was a major learning experience for most of those involved. There should be a point where the value of a post is determined by the weight of the interest in it, overriding the opinions of a few in the back-room OR using the letter of the law as a tool to find an excuse.
Simplistic overview:
Theists are angry that their belief/heritage is being challenged. Theists are also angry because they feel it is directed at them personally. That's not to say that there aren't comments that are personal but adults usually handle that without too much difficulty.
Non-theists are angry that theistic politics is pushing America toward a theocracy. Non-theists are many times angry because religious people or religious family members have abused them at some point in their lives, maybe psychologically, maybe physically.
My point is that though this was heated and nasty at times, it was anything but dysfunctional. This is the way people learn to BE functional. It was honest. It was emotional. That is what humans do to live and learn. Function is not found in pretence, suppression or dishonesty; it's found in discourse and expression. There is something to be said about "respect", but the definition of that word is where that problem lies. Respect does not disallow argument and it's not necessarily respectful to simply add niceties to the wording to give the disingenuous impression of acceptance. Respect is found in allowing others the right to their own experiences, ideas and maturity. No matter what the common meme is, you don't demand respect, you don't earn respect... you give respect.
One final thing: If it were possible to move such a thread, the real question would be whether it belonged in GD, Religion or Mental Health. ????
Sorry... had to say it... didn't know where else to put it. DF7