Religion
Related: About this forumMassachusetts Supreme Judicial Court To Hear Case Against Pledge Of Allegiance
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/10/31/massachusetts-supreme-court-case-against-pledge-of-allegiance_n_2047799.htmlReligion News Service | By Kimberly Winston
Posted: 10/31/2012 1:52 am EDT Updated: 10/31/2012 1:52 am EDT
(RNS) Massachusetts' Supreme Judicial Court has agreed to hear the appeal of a non-religious family that's challenging the mandatory daily recitation of the Pledge of Allegiance in their children's classrooms.
The family, who are secular humanists, claim that the phrase "under God" in the pledge is a violation of the state's constitutional ban on religious discrimination.
In June, a lower court ruled against the family, saying the required recitation of the pledge was not discriminatory because it did not uphold one religion over another. The family appealed, and will now gain a hearing from the state's highest court.
The battle to remove "under God" from the pledge has been a long and, so far, unsuccessful one within atheist circles. California atheist Michael Newdow unsuccessfully argued for its removal before the U.S. Supreme Court in 2004.
more at link
rrneck
(17,671 posts)defacto7
(13,485 posts)The lower court says, "the pledge was not discriminatory because it did not uphold one religion over another." Now that is what I call fishing for an out.
One nation under God, clearly defines a deity and puts the US under said deity. I am not under any deity and the US in my opinion is not under a deity.
The wording of the pledge is not really a problem for me personally; I not sweating it much because my children and I don't have to say it. But let's call it what it is first, not make up a bunch of unreasonable excuses for it.
When it comes to the problem of connecting any theistic idea with the state, there is danger. It's the danger we have right now... this election with zealots having found one more foothold to help them climb to their theocracy. "See, the US is under God!" Why would we want to let fanatics who have amassed large amounts of money convince the less educated masses that the US is under a deity, a Christian deity at that (by association, not by reasonable interpretation)? It creates decent, hate and discrimination while they are fighting to decide who's God is right. In my case it creates hatred and prejudice towards those who do not believe in a deity.
Look at it this way, A Baptist can say the pledge without lying, a practicing Jew can say it, a Mormon can say it, a Scientologist can say it, a Jehovah's Witness can say it (although they refuse), a Pentecostal can say it, a Hindu can say it, a Muslim can say it. All these people can say it... but an atheist cannot say the pledge of allegiance without lying.
Do what you will with the pledge, but until those recently added words are removed, my family cannot make that pledge. And let's stop lying about it's reason for inclusion. It is what it is. It is a statement by the state advocating that there is a god, and that is contrary to the equality of all Americans.
cbayer
(146,218 posts)general and, therefore, discriminates against those who do not have a religion.
I thought there had been a higher court ruling that at least stated that children could not be mandated to participate.
pinto
(106,886 posts)"I pledge allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America, and to the Republic for which it stands; one Nation indivisible with liberty and justice for all."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pledge_of_Allegiance#Addition_of_.22under_God.22
The Red Scare period...
rug
(82,333 posts)In NYC at least, there were many teachers who supported or were members of the CPUSA.
http://cup.columbia.edu/book/978-0-231-15268-6/reds-at-the-blackboard/excerpt
This was pure redbaiting.
trotsky
(49,533 posts)The Lemon test also says that a governmental action shouldn't promote religion in general over non-religion. What an ignorant court.
dimbear
(6,271 posts)a falsehood daily for years builds character somehow?
Oh, right, I'm the unreasonable one.