USCIRF hypocrisy: It's about the Protestant worldview, not religious freedom
May 11, 2015 15:10 IST
By Jakob De Roover
The annual reports of the US Commission for International Religious Freedom (USCIRF) have long irked politicians and citizens from countries placed on its watch list. This is no different in India. In the 2015 report released about a fortnight ago, the country again occupies an unenviable spot in Tier 2, which includes countries where the religious freedom violations engaged in or tolerated by the government are serious.
Striking about this years report, however, is its claim that incidents of religiously-motivated and communal violence have reportedly increased for three consecutive years in India. According to Muslim and Christian NGOs that track communal incidents, it adds, 2014 statistics, yet to be released by the ministry, will be likely higher than the 823 incidents recorded in 2013.
What is so remarkable about this? Well, the Indian home ministrys official data about communal incidents for 2014 give a very different picture. The number of incidents saw a significant decrease to 644 in 2014. The USCIRF report also includes Andhra Pradesh, Chattisgarhi [sic], and Odisha among states that tend to have the greatest number of religiously-motivated attacks and communal violence incidents. Yet the home ministrys information recorded no incident in Chhattisgarh, just three in Odisha, and five in Andhra Pradesh.
How reliable then are the international religious freedom reports of the US government? The obvious retort to this question is that the home ministrys data for 2014 must be very biased. But which other unbiased data could establish this bias? When asked this question, an American academic responded as follows: I dont have any data, but given who is in charge, it cant help but be biased. That, of course, is a knockdown argument.
http://www.firstpost.com/world/uncirf-hypocrisy-protestant-worldview-not-religious-freedom-2237900.html