"JURUPA VALLEY: School board to discuss Sikhs’ ceremonial kirpans"

To orthodox Sikhs throughout the world, the ceremonial kirpan is more than just a symbol. It is one of five sacred articles of faith that define the essence of the estimated 27 million Sikhs worldwide and must be worn at all times by baptized Sikhs.

In this context, Jurupa Unified School District officials have given permission for at least three Sikh students to wear a kirpan to school as long as the dagger-like articles are soldered or sewn into the sheath so they cannot be used.

“This is an issue of religious freedom and of faith,” said Mary Burns, the district’s longest-serving school board member. “Who am I to deny what is an article of faith of a 600-year-old religion?”

The kirpan is useful as an arm for self-defense regardless of its religious significance.

If the school board approves the kirpan, why not other arms such as a handgun?

10 replies, 739 views

Reply to this thread

Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum

Replies to this discussion thread

10 replies	Author	Time	Post
"JURUPA VALLEY: School board to discuss Sikhs’ ceremonial kirpans" (Original post)	jody	Nov 2012	OP
If it's soldered or sewn into the sheath, then it seems to become much less of a weapon	petronius	Nov 2012	#1
Because using a handgun as a weapon	JoeyT	Nov 2012	#2
"Using a kirpan as a weapon is forbidden..."	PavePusher	Nov 2012	#4
Is your handgun an article of faith?	SecularMotion	Nov 2012	#3
There is a sect of Church of the FSM that considers them sacred objects that should be with you at	ProgressiveProfessor	Nov 2012	#5
my sect of neo druids	gejohnston	Nov 2012	#6
OMG, a Cult!!1!11!!!	PavePusher	Nov 2012	#8
The term Beecher's Bible comes to mind. eom	jbgood1977	Nov 2012	#7
If you mean my 1911, you're damn straight it's an article of faith	slackmaster	Nov 2012	#9
The rules should be applied equally to everyone	4th law of robotics	Nov 2012	#10

Response to jody (Original post)

Sat Nov 3, 2012, 05:37 PM

petronius (19,653 posts)

1. If it's soldered or sewn into the sheath, then it seems to become much less of a weapon

and much more of the merely ceremonial. If your religion required you to carry a handgun, then I suppose the equivalent would be one with the barrel filled in (like in the theatre department), or glued into the holster...

Reply to this post

Response to jody (Original post)

Sat Nov 3, 2012, 05:48 PM

JoeyT (4,549 posts)

2. Because using a handgun as a weapon

isn't against anyone's religion. Using a kirpan as a weapon is forbidden, and many Sikhs consider it an insult when people imply they'd use it as a weapon.

Reply to this post

Response to JoeyT (Reply #2)

Sat Nov 3, 2012, 07:22 PM

PavePusher (15,374 posts)

4. "Using a kirpan as a weapon is forbidden..."

This may not be accurate.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kirpan

The kirpan has both a physical function, as a defensive weapon, as well as a symbolic function.

Reply to this post

Response to jody (Original post)

Sat Nov 3, 2012, 06:41 PM

SecularMotion (3,147 posts)

3. Is your handgun an article of faith?

Reply to this post

Response to SecularMotion (Reply #3)

Sat Nov 3, 2012, 08:31 PM

ProgressiveProfessor (22,144 posts)

5. There is a sect of Church of the FSM that considers them sacred objects that should be with you at

all times in case they run into aggressive non believers. However due to religious bigotry, the FSM is not accorded the same respect a xtianity and islam.

Reply to this post

Response to SecularMotion (Reply #3)

Sat Nov 3, 2012, 09:08 PM

gejohnston (12,587 posts)