Foreign Affairs
Related: About this forumLast Post in Iraq: this is the death knell of the American empire
So the Yanks are going home. Apart from the thousands of their servicemen and women whose lifeblood they are leaving in the sands of Iraq, and the tens of thousands too maimed or otherwise damaged to make it back to home and hearth. And minus the trillion-plus of dollars in treasure they have expended on destroying an Arab country (which may have lost a million souls and seen three millions off into exile), fanning the flames of fanaticism, making Iran more powerful, and unleashing a wave of sectarianism throughout the Muslim world. Nice work, but hardly "Mission Accomplished", as the melancholy valediction delivered by President Obama at Fort Bragg this week made clear to the discerning.
The more he talked about what he once called the "dumb war", the more obvious it was that his was the task of holding the dipped banner of defeat. And the crew of thick-necked servicemen straight out of central casting roaring their approval at his description of their success could not quite drown out the sound of the Last Post. This is the death knell of American empire, the end of the brief unipolar world in the ashes of whose hubris the lone bugler now stands playing the retreat. Like Ozymandias, history which hasn't ended after all will invite us to gaze upon its ruined works and tremble. But instead we will rejoice, rejoice. For the Project for the New American Century it will be never glad confident morning again.
The war that was waged yes, for oil, and yes, also for Israel was waged above all to terrify the world (especially China) with American power. It turned into the largest boomerang in history. For what has been demonstrated instead are the limits of near-bankrupt America's power. Far from being cowed, America's adversaries and its enemies have been emboldened. With shock and awe the empire soon dominated the skies over Iraq to be sure. But they never controlled a single street in the country from the day they invaded until this day of retreat. One street alone Haifa Street in Baghdad became the graveyard of scores, maybe hundreds of Americans.
Fortresses like Fallujah entered history alongside Stalingrad as symbols of the unvanquishable power of popular resistance to foreign invasion. Crimes like Abu Ghraib prison where Iraqis were stripped naked and humiliated, forced to perform indecent acts upon each other and videotaped doing so for the entertainment of their torturers in the barracks afterwards entered the lexicon of the barbarism of those who invade others, flying the colours of their "civilising" mission. As Chairman Mao once put it: "Sometimes the enemy struggles mightily to lift a huge stone; only to drop it on its own foot." In an America where a third of the population are living in poverty or terrifyingly near it, and where imperial hubris met its nemesis on Haifa Street, China now knows it has nothing to fear from this paper tiger.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2011/dec/15/iraq-death-knell-of-us-empire
jaxx
(9,236 posts)Pretty crappy to put down the US. If I remember there were plenty of Brits there too.
adamski
(13 posts)why would anyone think the war has ended. Troops moved to neighbouring countries ready for re-entry in case uS interests are threatened, the largest embassy in the world remains and a truck load of mercenaries. The end? Not a chance.
jaxx
(9,236 posts)We are still in Germany and Japan too. Are we still at war with them?
Excuse me?? Do these countries have an army of up to 17,000 under the nominal direction of the US State Department including a force of 5,500 private mercenary security contractors, a massive CIA station, and Special Operations troops operating covertly out of uniform not to mention tens of thousands of US troops being kept in place across the border and all this with the US Navy and the US Air Force remaining in control of the countrys coastlines and airspace.
Yeah, that's some ending of a war. A fine example of Orwell's doublespeak
Boston_Chemist
(256 posts)As you, and others stated, there are large mercenary armies operating in Iraq, still. And there are large amounts of personnel stationed at a convenient location, should things heat up. And I wouldn't be at all surprised if they did heat up.
Obama is running for reelection, isn't he?
Say he gets reelected, which is the most likely scenario. My bet is that troops will roll right back into Iraq after election season, on whatever excuse can be drummed up.
bemildred
(90,061 posts)Priceless!