Thu Feb 28, 2013, 02:05 PM
Joe Shlabotnik (3,930 posts)
Crown corporation weighs in on NDP housing bill
Non-partisan government website posts unattributed costs for opposition bill
A Crown corporation's decision to publicly comment on an NDP-backed bill is raising questions about whether the Conservative government is using the public service for partisan aims — again.
The Canadian Mortgage and Housing Corp. claims on its website that the New Democrats' proposal for a national housing strategy will cost "$5.5 billion per year in rental subsidies alone."
The figure is not explained by the CHMC, nor was it explained by Conservative MPs and their party who used it all day Wednesday in their attacks on the bill.
The sudden emergence of a dollar value from a non-partisan Crown corporation left New Democrats and observers scratching their heads.
From the group Canada without Poverty:
On behalf of the Conservative government, Tony Clement has spoken out against C-400 calling it a “dangerous new NDP spending scheme” for more social housing.
This is a completely false characterization of Bill C-400.
Let’s be very clear:
1) Bill C-400 is NOT a money bill.
2) It does NOT call for a new social housing program. It is about the development of a national housing strategy in keeping with human rights law.
Bill C-400 is not a “money bill”. As a private member’s bill it cannot allocate federal funds without Government approval. The cost of the housing strategy would depend on how the strategy is designed in collaboration with other governments and stakeholders.
We know, however, that addressing homelessness and inadequate housing in Canada would save governments significant amounts of money. Acting on homelessness is not just morally responsible, it’s fiscally responsible:
Homelessness costs the Canadian economy $4.5 billion each year (cost of emergency shelters, hospital visits, policing, lost productivity, etc.)
Bill C-400 is not about social housing. It is the first step in implementing a national housing strategy to implement the right to adequate housing. It ensures a coordinated and coherent response to the housing and homelessness crisis that engages a range of stakeholders including all levels of government.
From the file:
Conservative Party of Canada
Date: February 27, 2013
For immediate release
Harper Government Opposes Dangerous New NDP Spending Scheme
OTTAWA – Today, the Honourable Tony Clement, President of the Treasury Board, announced that the Harper Government will not support Bill C-400, which is NDP legislation that calls on the federal government to create a new national social housing strategy. Human Resources and Skills Development Canada estimates that the price tag for this legislation will be at minimum $5.5 billion per year.
“Week after week, we see Mulcair’s NDP continuing to demonstrate to Canadians their dangerous and risky spending schemes,” said Minister Clement. “At a time when we are trying to return to balanced Budgets, our Government will not support this risky and dangerous NDP spending scheme that will result in higher taxes or increased deficits,” said Minister Clement.
The NDP’s Bill C-400, which will be voted upon in the House of Commons today, calls for the establishment of a new national social housing strategy. This program would be on top of the $12 billion dollars the Government of Canada transfers to the provinces each year under the Canada Social Transfer. And, it is on top of the hundreds of millions of dollars the Government spends on affordable housing and homelessness each and every year.
“The Harper Government will continue to focus on what matters to Canadians – jobs, growth and long-term prosperity,” said Minister Clement. “We will not support a new spending program that will justify Thomas Mulcair imposing a $21 billion carbon tax on hardworking Canadian families,” added Minister Clement.
Not only do the Conservatives oppose a national housing strategy supported by all opposition parties, the Senate, and the UN, they further misrepresent the humanitarian bill and use it as a political attack, and once again misuse a nonpartisan crown corporation (à la CIDA scandal) for propaganda. These fuckers are pure evil.
2 replies, 664 views
Response to Joe Shlabotnik (Original post)
Fri Mar 1, 2013, 04:43 PM
MAD Dave (192 posts)
1. Bald-faced lies and deliberate diversions.
The CPC and PM Harper lie and obstruct the truth so well and so often that I doubt they actually know the truth anymore. They will do whatever they can to maintain power!
Response to MAD Dave (Reply #1)
Fri Mar 1, 2013, 05:20 PM
Joe Shlabotnik (3,930 posts)
2. and now the bill is dead
not surprising. Conservative times are hard times. Meanwhile this plus 2 other Conservative scandals broke yesterday; same as it ever was.