The DU Lounge
Related: Culture Forums, Support ForumsShould I buy a Smart car?
I live in the city, and parking is near impossible. [on street
Do any DUers own or know someone that does?
What are the opinions?
LynneSin
(95,337 posts)Much roomier than expected.
I also live in the city and when my Legacy dies I'm looking at that car or a Mini Cooper or a Fiat.
I don't use half of the car space that I own so why have such a big car.
nolabear
(41,938 posts)And it's cute as a button. Always important.
LynneSin
(95,337 posts)kwassa
(23,340 posts)His opinion:
There are better cars that get the same or better milage, and have more interior space, like the Honda Fit, which is a very popular vehicle.
The Smart car was radical when it was first introduced, but that was more than a decade ago in Europe. Now it has lots of competition.
and larger cars offer much more protection in an accident.
NV Whino
(20,886 posts)And having totaled my first FIT, I can attest to their safety. Second FIT is even better, and they carry a ton of stuff. MPG is 33 around town and up and down my hill. Took it to Sonoma a few weeks ago and got 34.5. I expect I could get 35 on the highway.
MrsBrady
(4,187 posts)the fit is go!
MuseRider
(34,095 posts)I bought it used, it is one of the originals that came over and were converted for use here. I love it. If I lived in the city and not out on the kinds of roads I have to drive it would be a better vehicle for me but still, I get 40 mpg routinely. Roomy enough that we have never had a problem, even with big grocery trips.
LWolf
(46,179 posts)snow, ice, dirt, and gravel?
MuseRider
(34,095 posts)Mine was one of the first brought over and there is nowhere to get it worked on so we go around and hit and miss. Anyway, it handles well. It does blow around on the highway but you have a lot of room in a lane to blow around in Trucks don't bother it at all. It was not meant for gravel. Most of my problems, and there really are not many, are from gravel. The newer models might be better. It sits very low so I have not driven it on dirt, snow I got caught in and it is not too bad but because of where we live I opt for my super heavy 4 wheel drive truck in snow and ice. We really had no challenge with snow and ice last year so I can't say more than that.
I like that it is small like me, fast and zippy, easy to handle, can pack an amazing amount of groceries in it, feels safe and really is and I never get less than 40 mpg. Every time I leave the farm I have to use a stretch of highway and that helps I am sure. It takes me about 1 1/2 minutes to fill up the 8 gallon tank
If you only have short stretches of gravel I would look into it. I have about a mile of it to get in or out of here. I would leave it home on snow and ice but then I am chicken and do not trust all the 4 wheel drivers who drive like it is a dry race track when it is slick as can be.
IOW, I love it but it does have it's limits out here.
LWolf
(46,179 posts)and dirt (where the gravel has worn down and the road hasn't been maintained) every time I leave or come home. My Tacoma handles everything just fine, I'd just like better mpg, so I'm always looking for a car that can handle ice, snow, dirt, and gravel.
HopeHoops
(47,675 posts)They're so small that I have trouble spotting them in our mini van. I've also noticed a propensity for drivers of them to think they can just cut right in front of larger vehicles. Sure, you can probably stop one of those in five feet at 65 (slight exaggeration), but a 3200 lb vehicle will still be working on slowing down for a LONG time.
Now in the city they make sense. I liked how Steve Martin (in the "Pink Panther" pulled his straight in between two parallel parked cars. If they dedicated sections of the parking zones to straight-in parking only for cars below a certain length, I think the trend would catch on, and you can put twice as many of those little things in the same space as larger cars.
As for my opinion of them, they aren't as ugly as that "Cube" thing, but I wouldn't call them attractive. But that aside, it does make sense for city life.
Pryderi
(6,772 posts)opiate69
(10,129 posts)sharp_stick
(14,400 posts)I'll just lift that to send to my cousin with the Smart Car.
MuseRider
(34,095 posts)Major Nikon
(36,818 posts)opiate69
(10,129 posts)cliffordu
(30,994 posts)just as well as anyone on this board....
flvegan
(64,407 posts)If I were looking to put a blight on my life for the next number of years, I'd get a Smart.
Here are 5 words never before spoken: I'd rather a Fiat 500.
If parking is the big obstacle, I'd offer these alternatives to the Smart, all much more comfortable, useful and more sound monetarily:
1. A pogo stick.
2. A Vespa.
3. A postage stamp on my forehead.
4. Used Yugo. No depreciation there, at least.
Joe Shlabotnik
(5,604 posts)but then again I'm always wary of anything qualified by the prefix "smart". Reminds me of 'surgical strikes' etc.
I rock a Vespa knock off. I love it. If I was going to buy an actual car again, it wouldn't be a smart car.
mikeytherat
(6,829 posts)Yugo cabrio. Those words should not exist together in any context, no matter how absurd and/or comical. Oh, and both of them were painted a flat Kenmore white, with white alloy wheels. The "I wanted so hard to be a VW Cabrio yet failed" vibe was palpable (and anyway, why would one aspire to be an '80s VW Cabrio?). If you thought they were bad with a tinfoil roof, you should have experienced the open-top version. Especially on the roads of southwestern Virginia. In the winter.
mikey_the_rat
Aristus
(66,294 posts)It's solidly built, incredible gas mileage, you can park it anywhere, it's a fun attention-getter, and it's big enough inside to seat comfortably my six-foot-six brother.
Go for it!...
aint_no_life_nowhere
(21,925 posts)and gets about the same gas mileage. And it's a lot of fun to drive. My 1961 Renault (like the one pictured below) is only 1200 lbs. whereas the Smart comes in at over 1600. And it carries 4 adults.
Tommy_Carcetti
(43,155 posts)That was my dad's first car about which he still waxes fondly.
aint_no_life_nowhere
(21,925 posts)Flaxbee
(13,661 posts)I think the Fit is probably a better car for your money than a Mini, however.
A good friend of mine has a Fit and she looooves it. Very good gas mileage, compact yet roomy - she and her two Labrador-sized dogs and boyfriend and camping gear fit in it quite comfortably...
Initech
(100,043 posts)Pryderi
(6,772 posts)4_TN_TITANS
(2,977 posts)Mercedes, and safer than you'd think. Still, doesn't get any better mileage than our Scion and more room in the Scion.
RedCloud
(9,230 posts)Every mile I have to hear it...
"What are you? Driving Miss Daisy?"
pipi_k
(21,020 posts)for city driving, but scary on the highway.
I personally wouldn't buy a car small enough to store in my purse when I'm done with it.
mysuzuki2
(3,521 posts)Pryderi
(6,772 posts)parking where I live, I thought the Smart car would be a good option.
mysuzuki2
(3,521 posts)Although parking in Milwukee is not as bad as in many other citys. The Smart just doesn't see m to be a good all around car. A mini or fiat is not thjat much bigger and should not be much harder to park than a smart. Just my opinion. If you never leave the city, ok. But if you ever get on the highway I think there are better choices. But, isn't it great to have choices?
Pryderi
(6,772 posts)drive anywhere on Friday or Saturday night or we won't be able to park when we get back.
We live near a party street in Pittsburgh on the South Side.
MrsBrady
(4,187 posts)love mine.
would buy another.
harmonicon
(12,008 posts)Remember Knight Rider? Kitt could be so condescending to Michael. I think you should always have a car that's dumber than you.
mikeytherat
(6,829 posts)mikey_the_rat
We are Devo
(193 posts)zipplewrath
(16,646 posts)She doesn't own a car. Lives in Chicago and "rents" through some co-op. She rents what she needs when she needs it. Been more than a decade now. She's very happy.
Pryderi
(6,772 posts)Tommy_Carcetti
(43,155 posts)Nothing against small cars in general.
Mini Coopers are cool: They remind you of The Italian Job. You can paint a British Flag on the top of them. They're cute. Etc.
VW Bugs are cool. Groovy, even.
Smart Cars, on the other, look like a golf cart, except less practical. And their mileage is not at the level where the practicality outweighs the uncoolness. You'd have to be looking at 60-70 mph before I'd even think of buying a Smart Car.
Shagbark Hickory
(8,719 posts)I mean... if "parking is impossible"... they still take up a parking space.
I don't think they'll fit in the elevator.
Shagbark Hickory
(8,719 posts)We are Devo
(193 posts)Shagbark Hickory
(8,719 posts)But they sure look real to me.
Pryderi
(6,772 posts)motorcyclists in wrecks.
progressoid
(49,952 posts)Engine started drinking oil and mileage dropped. The repairs would have cost nearly as much as the car itself! So they traded it for a Ford Focus.