Wed Feb 27, 2013, 11:29 PM
FarCenter (17,316 posts)
Ed Miliband should sack Ed Balls - and as brutally as possible
The Liberal Democratsí antics over Lord Rennard have obscured the truly dreadful performance of the shadow chancellor, Ed Balls
The truth is that Mr Balls isnít any good as shadow chancellor. This is an open secret in the Labour Party (where discussions about his successor are ongoing) and also I suspect the Treasury, which may prefer not to draw attention to the shadow chancellorís weakness because they no longer think of him as much of a threat.
Political journalists have also been aware of the Balls problem for some time. I think that we have failed to highlight it because we like the man. There is something splendidly human about his pugnacity, his sheer love of the game, his vulnerability and his passion. He is robust, engages in argument, gets up from the floor when he has been knocked down. It is particularly admirable that he has stayed in mainstream politics in the wake of Labourís 2010 defeat when so many of his former colleagues Ė James Purnell, Peter Mandelson, Alan Milburn etc, etc Ė have walked away to make money.
And yet, as shadow chancellor, he is a failure. Monday showed that he cannot damage George Osborne even if confronted with an easy target. There are various reasons for this, one of which is Mr Ballsís total identification with the economics and politics of the Gordon Brown era. The basic reason why Britain is in such an economic mess is because Mr Brown, advised by Mr Balls, spent too much and fuelled a boom. We are coping with the resulting bust. There is no getting away from this
3 replies, 602 views
Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
Ed Miliband should sack Ed Balls - and as brutally as possible (Original post)
|Angry Dragon||Feb 2013||#2|
Response to FarCenter (Original post)
Thu Feb 28, 2013, 12:25 AM
hrmjustin (64,963 posts)
3. The Tories tried in the last election to defeat him, but they just came up short.
Sounds like Labour would have wished he lost.