Fri Nov 16, 2012, 08:07 AM
xchrom (108,903 posts)
When Right-Wing Christians Stopped Thinking of Women as People
Photo illustration shows pro-life (R) and pro-choice demonstrators in Washington, DC.
In the autumn of 1978 the Washington Association of Churches and the Washington State Catholic Conference jointly published a six-page pamphlet they called “Abortion: An Ecumenical Study Document.” Their work offers a fascinating snapshot of Christian thinking at the time and raises some equally fascinating questions about what, exactly, has happened in the last 35 years.
The pamphlet does not contain a position statement. Quite the opposite, in fact. From the beginning, the authors explain that such an agreement is impossible: "Clearly there is no Christian position on abortion, for here real values conflict with each other, and Christian persons who seek honestly to be open to God’s call still find themselves disagreeing profoundly."
At the time, five years had passed since the Rove v. Wade decision, and the Church, broadly, was wrestling with ethical and spiritual complexities the decision brought to the surface. WAC, which existed “to express and strengthen the unity Christians have in Jesus Christ” had asked member denominations to create a study group because strong feelings on the question of abortion were threating that mission. In the absence of an agreement, the study group articulated a set of shared values and then assembled statements on abortion from member denominations.
Some of the contents would come as little surprise to anyone aware of today’s struggles over abortion ethics and rights. For example, the Catholic Church pronounced that even when pregnancy threatens a mother’s life, abortion “increases the overall tragedy.” Catholicism has wavered over the centuries about when a fetus becomes a person with a soul, but the hierarchy has been consistent in its opposition to abortion after ensoulment, which is now proclaimed to happen at conception. Furthermore, the Catholic hierarchy has long sought to enforce its ethical judgments via civic and criminal codes, and 1978 was no exception: “A legal context in which abortion is presented as a legitimate way of resolving tragic situations creates an atmosphere that reduces respect for the value of life. Ultimately, such an atmosphere dehumanizes the lives of all who live in it.”
8 replies, 1039 views
Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
When Right-Wing Christians Stopped Thinking of Women as People (Original post)
Response to xchrom (Original post)
Fri Nov 16, 2012, 10:44 AM
Tsiyu (18,078 posts)
6. Although the RC church normally is anti-war
Many Fundy, anti-choice American Christians are VERY pro-war.
I've tried asking a few of them if they believe our soldiers should have gone in and got all the pregnant women out of harm's way in Iraq and Afghanistan before we started bombing.
"How many unborn died in those wars? Where is your vast love and concern for those fetuses? Where is your sense of the value of THOSE little lives?"
Eternal response? :
Response to xchrom (Original post)
Fri Nov 16, 2012, 11:09 AM
liberal_at_heart (12,081 posts)
8. religious men around the globe have subjugated women since
the beginning of time. We will never be completely free of it. We will always have to be vigilant and ready to fight for women all over the globe. But yes, it does seem that American Christians have lost patience because they have not been able to put women back in their place since the revolution of the 1960's.