Welcome to DU! The truly grassroots left-of-center political community where regular people, not algorithms, drive the discussions and set the standards. Join the community: Create a free account Support DU (and get rid of ads!): Become a Star Member Latest Breaking News General Discussion The DU Lounge All Forums Issue Forums Culture Forums Alliance Forums Region Forums Support Forums Help & Search

General Discussion

Nanjeanne

(5,044 posts)

8. Would like to see Egypt's proposal agreed to by Israel and Hamas

Reply to TheProle (Original post)

Thu Apr 25, 2024, 01:30 PM

Apr 25

Egypt's proposal to Israel:
1) Suspend Rafah invasion prep
2) Full hostage release; release of hundreds of Palestinian prisoners
3) Absolute 1-year ceasefire
4) During ceasefire, steps toward creating Palestinian state. US, Egypt, Jordan, PA would support

Edit history

Please sign in to view edit histories.

22 replies

= new reply since forum marked as read

Highlight:

Hamas official says group would lay down its arms if an independent Palestinian state is established [View all] TheProle Apr 25 OP

From the group that broke the cease fire and committed the October 7th attack. JohnSJ Apr 25 #1

If we are just to consider october's attack not the whole history. northern light Apr 25 #2

Might be worth exploring... if peace is really the goal... and not just new beach front hotels and resorts WarGamer Apr 25 #3

Perhaps shell game more than Other, but I believe the offer is mostly honest sarisataka Apr 25 #4

I do not believe them. Happy Hoosier Apr 25 #5

And Hamas knows that so the offer is suspect, to say the least. nt Biophilic Apr 25 #11

Then produce the hostages and we'll begin with a cease fire. FalloutShelter Apr 25 #6

Hamas propose that Israel gives them everything comradebillyboy Apr 25 #7

Would like to see Egypt's proposal agreed to by Israel and Hamas Nanjeanne Apr 25 #8

That is proably the best either side can get at the moment sarisataka Apr 25 #9

I feel they should just become a state. No strings attached. LeftInTX Apr 25 #13

After the damage Israel has done ripcord Apr 25 #10

I say let them become a state. They will then be responsible for their own actions. LeftInTX Apr 25 #12

Hamas has even less integrity than Mitch McConnel. chouchou Apr 25 #14

I am sure hams will agree to the truce. The question is, will it abide by it? Beastly Boy Apr 25 #15

They won't know if they don't take the offer. Ping Tung Apr 25 #16

Their a bunch of lying terrorists JustAnotherGen Apr 25 #17

Exactly. You don't negotiate with terrorists. You wipe them the fuck out 100%. Fuck that so-so shit. SoFlaBro Apr 25 #18

But, Gen, don'tcha know, you're supposed to negotiate with people like Duke. Behind the Aegis Apr 25 #19

You betcha! JustAnotherGen Apr 25 #20

Trying to gain traction and sympathy. lees1975 Apr 25 #21

I'm confused by what part of release the hostages and surrender unconditionally isn't getting processed? TheKentuckian Apr 25 #22